Pete Miller's Seafood and Prime Steak - Evanston

Pete Miller's Seafood and Prime Steak - Evanston

1557 Sherman Ave Evanston, IL 60201, 60201-4897, United States Reservation
3930 Reviews 4.1

"Pete Miller's is an overlooked and underappreciated restaurant in Evanston."

Details

Phone: +18473280399

Address: 1557 Sherman Ave Evanston, IL 60201, 60201-4897, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Evanston

Website: http://www.petemillers.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 16:30 -22:00

Tuesday: 16:30 -22:00

Wednesday: 16:30 -22:00

Thursday: 16:30 -23:00

Friday: 16:30 -00:00

Saturday: 16:30 -00:00

Sunday: 16:30 -22:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 3930


Address

Show Map

Reviews

2.25 /5 Rating

Went for Downtown Dining Week. This restaurant was on the $35 list, however service was significantly below that level. There was a long wait between courses, but plates were not cleared off the table until the next course arrived. Our server appeared very disinterested in our table. It also took a long time for drink orders to be delivered. New silverware was not provided and I was explicitly asked to remove my fork from the plate so the server could clear the plate. The food was decent to good, but nothing special. None of these issues would be that bad had they not all occurred or had the restaurant been on the $25 list instead.

4.5 /5 Rating

We were in Milwaukee for a convention and noticed that Pier 106 was the only seafood restaurant around so decided to give it a try. Its right on the Riverwalk so a great location especially for those who like to sit outside (we didn't). We had great service and our meal was very good. We enjoyed an appetizer of mussels & clams which had white sauce over them - sauce reminded me of New England clam chowder - very different than what we expected but delicious. I had the stuffed salmon as my entrée and my husband had the ahi tuna - both dishes were very good. I'd recommend Pier 106 to anyone visiting Milwaukee.

3.25 /5 Rating

This might be a gem of a place but the night we had dinner they had little staff, the food took a long time to get to our table and then seemed over the top. Unfortunately it was too cold, otherwise this seems like the perfect place to sit outside on the terrace overlooking the river, outdoors and full of energetic city vibes.

1.5 /5 Rating

Ask for ahi tuna, they didn't have it. That knocked out about 1/3 of the menu. Ordered mussels + clams. Clams were undercooked and didn't even open. Mussels were empties for about half of them. Waitresss was new and apologetic, I hope she finds a new job Book a table now

1.5 /5 Rating

The food wasn't hot, lukewarm at best. The server was unable to answer simple questions about the menu or the fireworks cruise after dinner. Very disappointed with the whole meal. Fireworks we are great!

5 /5 Rating

My boyfriend and I decided to have a nice dinner dateIt was very classy and simpleStaff was very friendly and the waiter was amazing.

1 /5 Rating

The restaurant did not honor our gift card. They also did not call my husband back when he wanted to speak to a manager.

4.5 /5 Rating

What an amazing place to dine and relax. We were able to sit outside and gaze at the river while enjoying our meal. Book a table now

3.75 /5 Rating

Delicious food and Kelly took good care of us. Can't wait to try other menu items.

4 /5 Rating

Pete Miller's is an overlooked and underappreciated restaurant in Evanston.


Dishes

Pete's Chocolate Brownie Sundae
Pete's Chocolate Brownie Sundae

Flourless Chocolate Mousse Cake
Flourless Chocolate Mousse Cake

Classic Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Classic Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

25Th Anniversary Pete 'S Cut
25Th Anniversary Pete 'S Cut

North Atlantic Salmon Filet
North Atlantic Salmon Filet

Spinach: Sautéed Or Creamed
Spinach: Sautéed Or Creamed

The Forest Avenue Sandwich
The Forest Avenue Sandwich

Oysters On The Half Shell
Oysters On The Half Shell

The Davis Street Sandwich
The Davis Street Sandwich

Twin Maine Lobster Tails
Twin Maine Lobster Tails