I stopped by for some pizza and wings and was surprised to see new ownership, so I decided to give it a shot. BIG MISTAKE! The pizza was a complete disappointment; the dough was flavorless, and the sauce was overwhelmingly salty. I had requested a crispy crust, but that didn't come across clearly. Instead, the crust wasn't crispy at all, and to top it off, both slices were placed on top of each other in the same box! The wings were dry and seemed like they had been overcooked or reheated too many times. Needless to say, I won’t be returning to this restaurant.
Pirates Pizza - Table reservation
South Orange Avenue, South Orange, 07079, United States Of America Reservation"Great wings, amazing garlic knots, and excellent pizza! This place is a favorite"
Details
Phone: +19737626286
Address: South Orange Avenue, South Orange, 07079, United States Of America
Reservation, Booking
City: South Orange
Opening hours
Unfortunately, the opening hours are not available at the moment.Statistics
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 25
Address
Reviews
The pizza was just average, and the onion rings were quite disappointing. Furthermore, their business practices feel a bit underhanded. I ordered a half Veg/plain pizza over the phone, and the person at the counter failed to inform me about additional charges for the veggie toppings, which ended up costing me an extra $10. While I was in the store, I overheard an older customer expressing her confusion about why her sandwich cost $22. There are many other great pizza places nearby; I would recommend steering clear of this one.
New owners. Prices changed. not only that, they stopped delivering on sundays, the busiest day in football season and you wont deliver. Ridiculous. Pizza kinda downgraded in taste. But i mean if theres no other pizzeria around then i guess. But if theyre not gonna deliver, then u can literally pick up a better pie literally up the street.
Today was my 1st time here this is a hidden gem because I've been going down the street to trattoria which prices are ridiculously expensive so I would go all the way to Florham Park to Nonnas This is a new pizza spot pizza is very good crust is crunchy yet soft check this place out for yourself right next to Walgreens Book a table now
It’s alright, had the pepper, onions, and sausage speciality pizza. The peppers were a little thick and the sauce lacked flavor. Great crust though and sausage was great as well. Threw a little garlic and red pepper on it and it improved the sauce quality.
I’m kind of upset I took so long to try this spot. Their food is really high quality. Everything always tastes fresh, hot, and delicious. I’ve had them like 4 times now it always hits the spot. Just really good overall.
My favorite Pizzeria . I have been going here since I was in highschool, so it has now been 14 years . The pizza has been consistent even throughout all the years . The owner is fantastic ! Loyal customer here!
I always see Kori at this restaurant. She tends to eat the leftover slices I leave behind. Honestly, I don't mind at all because the food is fantastic and the service is excellent! Book a table now
Honestly, speaking for the first time since the pandemic I can say that the food is decent. Yes, I
Great wings, amazing garlic knots, and excellent pizza! This place is a favorite
Dishes
Book a table now
Categories
-
Delivery Services
-
Sandwiches
-
Mexican
-
Cheese
-
Pizza
Amenities
-
Parking Area
-
Reservations
-
Delivery
- Table reservation
-
Wifi
- Reservation
Dragon Phoenix
179 Main St, 07050-3728, City of Orange, United States
Reservation, Vietnamese, Chicken , Seafood, Asian, Lunch
"Fried rice is really good. It's a hit or miss restaurant."
Ms. Lin Chinese Cuisine
59 Main St, 07041-1305, Millburn, United States
Reservation, Asiatic, Chinese, Asian, Lunch, Fish
"Delicious food, ready on time, and well packaged. Friendly staff!"
Taco's Mexican Grill
1201 Springfield Ave, Irvington, United States
Reservation, Breakfast, Mexican, Coffee, Soup, Fish
"Great place to visit. The food was delicious. The prices were good and the workers were very polite"
The Weekend Spot
683 Springfield Ave, Newark, United States
Reservation, Puerto Rican, Breakfast, American, Cakes, Fish
"Love the corn bread. The shrimp scampi is amazing. The owner is so sweet."
Sum Ramen
188 Essex St, Millburn, NJ 07041, USA, United States
Reservation, Curbside Pickup, Ramen Noodles, Vegetarian, Japanese, Ramen
"Great food and service. My family love it. We will be back."