Pizzaiolo By Brothers

Pizzaiolo By Brothers

85 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA, 07432-1949, MIDLAND PARK, United States Reservation
4.4 /5
1575 Reviews

"Food and service was excellent. Would definitely go back."

Details

Phone: (+1)2014444944

Address: 85 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA, 07432-1949, MIDLAND PARK, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: MIDLAND PARK

Website: https://www.pizzaiolobrothers.com

Opening hours

Monday: 11:00-21:00

Tuesday: 11:00-21:00

Wednesday: 11:00-21:00

Thursday: 11:00-21:00

Friday: 11:00-22:00

Saturday: 11:00-21:30

Sunday: 11:00-21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1575


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Cielo

1/5

Walked in with a reservation. Restaurant failed to reserve a table for us. Once seated at a table not accommodating for our party of 5, no one ever greeted us, apologized for the wait,nor took our drink order. We were completely disregarded. After waiting over 30 minutes with no one ever approaching our table or checking in on us, we decided to leave. We have been loyal customers frequenting Pizzaiolo on the average of 2 times per month over the past 8 years. We’ve experienced a decline in the service since the manager left along with one of our favorite, long-standing waitresses. The experience is just not the same and this last visit was the clincher. It’s such a shame because it’s our fav...

Ettie

5/5

Absolutely love this place! All decorated for Christmas! So cute! So safe even have outdoor seating which is such a plus! So many places don’t have outdoor seating! The food is unforgettable they have THE BEST sweet potato fries, bruschetta, salad coffee! Oh my gawdddd the coffeeeee is to die for! 10000/10000 recommend getting the gingerbread latte!

Cheyanne

2/5

The starters were delicious. However, the main course lacked in aroma. The service was excellent. It is important to take into account the calculation of the extra tip. A six dollar charge for credit card use is too high. Overall, I would not return or recommend this restaurant to others.

Frank

1/5

The appetizers were delicious, but the main dishes lacked flavor. The service was excellent. The calculation of the tip added needs to be reviewed. Charging six dollars for using a credit card is excessive. Unfortunately, I would not return or recommend this restaurant to others. Book a table now

Kayla

3/5

The service at the restaurant was excellent. However, the food was just average. While nothing was bad, there was nothing that stood out or made us want to return.

Nona

4/5

Everyone enjoyed! Been dying to get there forever- will definitely be back. Perfect for families, small kids to grandparents!

RichardE

5/5

Possibly the best pizza in the area! Everything else on the menu is also delicious. This is a great spot for a casual meal.

Cielo

3/5

Always a great experience from a wonderful family who cooks great food and cares about their customers! Book a table now

Nona

4/5

The food delicious but the service very poor. We were asking for things 2-3 times.


Dishes

Harvest Chicken Croissant Specialty Sandwich
Harvest Chicken Croissant Specialty Sandwich

Broccoli Rabe And Sausage Specialty Pizza
Broccoli Rabe And Sausage Specialty Pizza

Pizzaiolo Italian Hero Specialty Sandwich
Pizzaiolo Italian Hero Specialty Sandwich

Wheat Crust Bruschetta Specialty Pizza
Wheat Crust Bruschetta Specialty Pizza

Grandma’s Margherita Specialty Pizza
Grandma’s Margherita Specialty Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Specialty Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Specialty Pizza

Tri Color Tortellini In Broth Soup
Tri Color Tortellini In Broth Soup

Broccoli And White Specialty Pizza
Broccoli And White Specialty Pizza

Tomato And White Specialty Pizza
Tomato And White Specialty Pizza

Creamy Artichoke Specialty Pizza
Creamy Artichoke Specialty Pizza