Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"Spectacular pizza! Very similar to a real Italian pizza. They have indoor and outdoor seating and a small parking lot"
Phone: +12404673210
Address: 4800 Rhode Island Ave, 20781, Hyattsville, US, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Hyattsville
Website: http://www.eatyourpizza.com/
Wednesday: 16:00-21:00
Thursday: 16:00-21:00
Friday: 13:00-21:00
Saturday: 13:00-21:00
Sunday: 13:00-21:00
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 1996
I have read some of the reviews before I ordered and thought I was in for a real treat. I love italian food and often go to Filomena's in Georgetown, so I was excited to have a more authentic italian experience closer to my house. This wasnt what I was hoping for. We ordered the antipasti and recieved 1 whole cherry pepper, ricotta cheese, and prosciutto. Then the pizza generally the prosciutto when put on a pizza it is cut so that its easier to eat. The other issue is that the pizza was flat it had no finish, perhaps they should consider finishing it with some balsamic. The final insult is that I ordered a coke and got a diet coke. I am extremely disappointed.
I got the Macellaio Pizza with mushrooms added. Unfortunately, not what I expected given the reviews. The crust was over baked and a bit too hard for my liking and it left a weird aftertaste and there was barely any sauce, so the pizza was extremely dry. The parking is not the best either, but that's just what comes with that neighborhood. The positives are that the toppings were fresh and the staff was friendly, but for $30 for a 12 inch pizza I could have gotten better pizza from elsewhere. I won't be back.
This place is very relaxing, specially on Fridays after a long week of work, I come to this place with my wife and my little one, the pizza is delicious, the atmosphere is relaxing, I recommend getting a outdoor table on week days you can watch the trains passing by across the street, the beer selection is also very good, I love it I tried to visit whenever possible!
My experience with this restaurant was terrible. They only gave my Uber Eats driver half of my order and didn't even try to fix the mistake when I called them. They blamed the driver and left me stuck paying $63 for a single small pizza. This place has been declining in quality for some time now, but this experience was the final straw. Book a table now
I visited Pizzeria Paradiso in Hyattsville after a long bike ride, and I was hungry. I ordered the Bosco pizza and added lamb meatballs. This pizza hit the spot! The lamb was terrific and is a little spicy. I also tried the pumpkin tiramisu, which was light and delightful. Nelson provided wonderful recommendations and customer service.
Pizza was delicious with interesting topping options and combinations, a good beer list with lots of craft options, a ton of local liquors on offer, and some of the best service I've ever received. Cannot recommend this place enough, definitely going to be our go to pizza spot.
Got a vegan mozzarella 9”. Ordered pesto as a topping and no tomato sauce or regular cheese. Could not taste the pesto. Pizza was extremely dry!
I love brick oven pizza, so I decided to try this place out. The pizza was delicious and the staff were very welcoming and friendly. Book a table now
The 9-inch sausage and pepperoni pizza was fantastic! The beer selection was also great. We will definitely be coming back!
Spectacular pizza! Very similar to a real Italian pizza. They have indoor and outdoor seating and a small parking lot
