We ordered takeout tonight for a group of six. We ordered some apps and sandwiches. The pizza rolls were ok but didn 't come with the marinara mentioned on the menu. The mozzarella sticks were what you would expect but also missing marinara. The disco taters had a splash of gravy and no identifiable cheese. Gross. Someone ordered the Portly Cordon Bleu but it had what seemed to be a breath of chicken breast on it; like the shavings you would see after the chicken was sliced in the deli. It was 80% bread, a slice of ham, probably ? cheese, and mustard on stale bread. Another person ordered the Portly Cheesesteak. It was also served on the same stale bread as previously mentioned and had a sne...
Came into Sayville with my daughter and wasn't sure what we wanted for lunch. We decided on sandwiches and thought that Portly Villager sounded interesting. So glad we chose to stop there. We got beers on tap and macaroni and cheese bites to start. Good start, but the sandwiches were unbelievable!!! My daughter got the smokehouse turkey. The turkey was so flavorful that it tasted as if it was shaved straight off of the turkey. I got the Italian sandwich. Hands down in my top two Italian sandwiches ever!! The sandwiches were piled high and came with a bag of chips and a side of macaroni salad. Neither of us could finish even half of the sandwich. We took home what we couldn't finish and are l...
update depending who is in the kitchen determines the sizeof the sandwich!! First off, Matt, the bartender/waiter was really awesome! His service was top notch! We ordered chicken wings and the pastrami sandwich. Their wings were one of the best we’ve ever had. They were so juicy and crispy! The pastrami sandwich was piled so high and we know why they call it the Katz meow. Moist and delicious and perfect amount of fat ratio! It is right up there next to Katz Deli! We travel for food and had to try this place! The sign “hearty sandwiches” drew us in. So happy we stopped in!
This restaurant is a lovely place for sandwiches, and their selection of beers is quite enjoyable. I really like how they highlight the history of Sayville; it adds a nice touch to the ambiance. However, the door is quite loud when you walk in, which sometimes makes me feel like I've startled an animal. Overall, I would give the food a 5, the service a 4, and the atmosphere a 2.
Book a table now
This charming pub might get a little loud, but it serves delicious tavern-style food and provides excellent service. You can expect to spend about $10–20 per person. Food rating: 5/5. Service rating: 5/5. Atmosphere rating: 3/5. Be sure to try the Cuban sandwich and macaroni salad!
Nice establishment that makes the most of its limited space. The food comes in a nice big basket and the service is friendly, just slightly understaffed. Worth checking out if you like to bar hop!
Ice cold beer and wings, what's better? This neighborhood bar is always welcoming and cozy. Winters are great with the fireplace and outside area out back in the summer!
Nice place for a late night drink in Sayville. Would recommend. Only thing was music was alittle too loud for me.
Book a table now
Ice cold beer, good food and a great, friendly staff and clientele. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Price per person: $20–30
Food: 4/5
Service: 4/5
Atmosphere: 4/5
