I order Primo's Pizzeria yesterday for a late lunch. My boyfriend and I got a plain pie and fried raviolis. It was absolutely delicious!! We ordered online for a delivery but the nice woman who works there called us right away to inform us that she didn't have any delivery drivers. I appreciated how fast she called to let us know and how sweet she was over the phone! We didn't mind, so we went and picked up our order. It was ready as soon as we got there and everything was hot and tasty! My boyfriend said when he went into the restaurant the woman was just as sweet as she was on the phone! We will definitely be ordering from here again!!!
Next, the $14 calamari order was half the portion of what other places offer for just $10. That's strike two. We also requested extra sauce and were willing to pay for it, but it never came.
Lastly, the wings were disappointing—greasy and small. We asked for the hot sauce on the side, but it seems the message was missed. That's strike three.
Overall, while the pizza was very good, that’s where the positives end.
If you're looking for delicious, authentic pizza, I highly recommend Primo's Pizza. It's conveniently located right next to ShopRite. They are generous with their portion sizes, so you're definitely getting your money's worth. The pizzeria is clean, the staff is friendly, and the quality of the food earns a solid 5 stars from me!
My wife and I have had pizza here a few times. The plain pie and garlic knots are similar to anywhere else. But the other day we had their grandma pie which was just awesome. Never had one like that before where it was like a flat style sicilian with heavy garlic flavor. Pretty much this is our new goto since having that pie.
Book a table now
It's great to see a new tenant in the space that was formerly Frank's Pizza. I only tried a slice, but the staff was friendly, and the pizza was quite cheesy. It has a similar vibe to Frank's, but the atmosphere is brighter since all the lights are on. Unfortunately, like Frank's, the bathroom is currently out of order.
This pizzeria is subpar, especially compared to the handful of pizza places in Sayreville. The dough was undercooked, their vodka sauce pizza was flavorless, and way overpriced for what you get (I don’t mind paying for good quality food). I’m not sure if there are new owners, but the quality went from okay to subpar.
Glad this place is close to home... I get the very reasonably priced eggplant parmesan... Nice bread... I just inhale the nicely packed hot sub.. I may just get it well done next time with some fresh garlic... Thumbs up.
I don't understand why this bad rating for the restaurant, I think it deserves a 5 star rating, the food is excellent, the staff, the owner everyone is very cool. Definetly worth visiting
Book a table now
Pizza needs work but the people are very nice
Good pizza!
