If you want excellent pizza with competitive pricing this is your pizzeria for the Town of East Islip and surrounding areas. The owner always greets me promptly by name with a smile. Customer experience is excellent here. They have many different types of pizza to choose from and can always make custom pizzas per request. The food is always delivered warm and delicious right to my door free of charge. I would highly suggest this pizzeria if you are looking for a nice atmosphere, good price and great quality tasting food.
I've been enjoying meals here since I was a kid, and the pizza has remained consistently excellent. The pinwheels, cheesesteak, garlic knots, and Vanilla Coke are all fantastic. Renzo's is a delicious neighborhood staple in the East Islip area. I highly recommend the Buffalo slice, the chicken bacon ranch slice, and the classic pepperoni. The spinach pinwheels are filled with spinach and cheese—so good!
Very good pizza. You can tell they use high quality ingredients. There food is always Very good and consistent. They have been there Forever, they must be doing something right. Also a plus the owner is always there and Pleasant along with the staff. Another plus Is the place always looks very clean. I highly recommend you give them a try.
Renzos pizza is one of the many local pizza spots in East Islip. They offer a full contingent of the standard Italian menu items found in most pizza shops on Long Island. I can only speak to their pizza so far, and it's good. They actually cook the pie, unlike so many others that have a soft undercooked Wonder Bread type crust.
Book a table now
It took 2 days to eat the pie : . It was delicious and the amount you get for the price is amazing. My family came from Florida and wanted real NY pizza. The best pizza out here in East Islip area. The staff was also very friendly. I'm glad we found this hidden jewel.
The owners have changed but they have maintained their quality. Sauce and mozzarella were great. Pizza was not floppy and had a strong undercarriage. Their garlic knots were the showstopper! Very garlicy with a hint of parmesan and butter. Delicious!
I stopped by this restaurant for lunch after visiting Pat’s Marketplace next door. It was a fantastic place! I really enjoyed the pizza, and the prices were very reasonable!
The owners were unfriendly and seemed like they didn't care about my business. The pie was good, but I won't be returning.
Book a table now
As I ponder life in front of a slice of delicious Mama’s ‘za in oakdale, I’m reminded of Enzo’s failures.
Best pizza around! The owners are awesome! Must try??
