"Good cod bites, homemade fries. Good pizza. Friendly, efficient staff and cold tap beer. I'll be back."
So his was my first time here. The parking lot is always very full so we decided to try it. They are famous for an item called “Toasties” so we got some. They were good. Basically they are meatballs. I ordered shrimp scampi and my husband chicken Marcella. Also garlic bread. We were a little confused because there were waitresses that came to us to take our order. We seemed to order 3 times. The shrimp scampi wasn’t garlicky it was in a cream sauce. It was ok. The wait for the check was a little long but in defense they got busy. I was not a fan of mine. Husband liked his. The price for the two of us was 67.00 I would try it again I like to give a place two try’s unless it’s real bad
Great place for lunch or dinner. We had two 14 pizzas one with pepperoni and sausage and one called nicks special that has sausage onion peppers and mushrooms. Both were cooked perfectly. Nice and thin with a good chew to the crust. The place has a good ambiance and plenty of parking. I also got a stuffed artichoke to take home. Real nice!! Moderately priced and worth every penny.
Good food and beer. Staff and owners of this restaurant are truly hospitable and this place has a very homely yet non-commercial vibe. Everyone seemed to know everyone (guests and staff) and it shows that most people are regulars here. The shrimp appetizer was great. Pizzas were solid. Would recommend this spot to others in the area
Best Italian food in NJ. Love everything I've ordered here, especially the gnocchi with gorgonzola sauce and their pizza! Great service and atmosphere. Worth the wait. We always stop here when we're in the area, just wish they were open on Sundays lol
Book a table now
Pizza is well above average. Salads are good. Shrimp scampi was reportedly just ok. Escarole and bean soup was underseasoned by a long way. Service was excellent. Very crowded and somewhat cramped. That pizza, though... absolutely worth it.
Staff is wonderful Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pizza Cheese, Chicken Franchise over Capellini, Meatball Parm, Chicken Parm, Marguerite Pizza
Fantastic pizza! Garlic and clam was fantastic- we liked it better then Lombardi’s or Delornzos out of Trenton area. The margarita was solid as well. Super crispy crunchy crust.
I absolutely adore this restaurant! It's definitely among the top three pizza spots in North Jersey. I highly recommend it! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Book a table now
The history of this place! First time visit, we had a great experience, delicious food, highly recommend the Reservoir Tavern
Good cod bites, homemade fries. Good pizza. Friendly, efficient staff and cold tap beer. I'll be back.
