Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"Nice place. Cost more than other places but big scoops. Nice play area kids."
Phone: +17172921400
Address: 121 South Main Street, Dover, 17315, United States Of America
Reservation, Booking
City: Dover
Website: http://sarahscreamery.com
Monday: 12:00-21:00
Tuesday: 12:00-21:00
Wednesday: 12:00-21:00
Thursday: 12:00-21:00
Friday: 12:00-22:00
Saturday: 12:00-22:00
Sunday: 12:00-21:00
Dishes: 7
Categories: 5
Reviews: 4348
So I would be giving 5 stars if it wasn't for the high prices and terrible rewards. I've been going to Sarah's like once a week with different family members visiting and we all 3 always get larges which I believe ran us close to 8 dollars which was okay because it's amazing ice cream and a cute little shop that smells like vanilla, but after spending close to 80 dollars I feel like something better than 2 dollars off my next 8 dollar ice cream should be offered. After realizing it wasn't a free small or medium and it was just 2 dollars off, I haven't been back. We tried macks which wasn't nearly as tasty but it also was half the price Cookie Monster is literally the only flavor I ever get...
Ice cream is good. Ordered a shake through Greer's next door from here. Had to wait in the Sarah's line for 30-40 minutes for the ONE employee on duty to turn around and take the already made shake out of a fridge. I mean come on. That long a wait to retrieve an already paid and made product? I know Greer's is its own place and the coordination can be hard but between two businesses find another solution than waiting in another line as your food gets cold. Absolutely ridiculous. You gotta find a better way.
My husband and I love their ice cream a little too much! It is absolutely delicious. However, they no longer offer my favorite flavor, Rice Krispy! I understand it may be due to low demand but I am disappointed. Nevertheless, all the other flavors are fantastic. I highly recommend this place! Please bring back my favorite flavor! Ratings: Food: 5, Service: 5, Atmosphere: 5.
This charming ice cream shop is a hidden gem. I sampled a homemade flavor, as well as one of their specialties, Cotton Candy and Coffee Break. Both were delicious. The staff was welcoming and happy to assist with any inquiries we had. We chose to sit outside, but there was ample seating both indoors and outdoors. Book a table now
I was pleasantly surprised to find such a great vegan ice cream option in a rural area with limited choices in Dover. The quality of the vegan ice cream here exceeded my expectations. I was especially thrilled to finally have butter pecan ice cream after five years of being vegan!
The ice cream at this restaurant is fantastic, although a little pricey. The staff are very friendly and the atmosphere is charming, with occasional entertainment. The location is convenient and easy to locate.
The service at this restaurant is always exceptional and the flavors are delicious. I particularly enjoy being able to get Penn State Ice Cream so conveniently close to home.
There are a lot of fantastic vegan choices available at this restaurant, and the portion sizes are generous, so come hungry! Book a table now
The restaurant offers a variety of delicious vegan options. The portions are generous, so come hungry!
Nice place. Cost more than other places but big scoops. Nice play area kids.
