Well what can I say? Appetizing seafood chowder and sirloin steak that melts in your mouth certainly met my expectations of this incredible dining experience yielded by a very friendly and welcoming staff especially the owners who ensured I was taken care of. For a busy night I was served relatively quick and my steak was cooked exactly as I had desired. This is one of the few establishments that actually cooks steak medium rare so that is a major plus. I have never felt so welcomed despite not being from this area. Definitely looking forward to future visits to this amazing establishment. Thank you so much.
First time going here despite being 10 minutes away and hearing rave reviews. Food was excellent. I had the traditional fried calamari which was very good and seasoned perfectly. The Ribeye steak was cooked perfectly medium rare with great flavor. The baked potato was kind of lack luster even for a potato, but it was fine. Overall plenty of food and fair prices despite rising food costs. My buddy had the fish and chips which looked good and his wife had the pot pie which was huge and looked very good. We were stuffed and did not have dessert.
What could possibly be better on a gloomy January day than having a pint with some Steamers and a Reuben at “the best” locally known Irish Pub in North New Jersey? I’ll wait… #thehungryagent #sheridanslodge #lakeilliff #andovernj #sussexcountynj #localseatbetter #steamers #reubensandwich #irishpub #localrealtornj #listingagent #buyersagent #njrealtor Sheridan's Restaurant and Tavern The Addison Group
The cheeseburger was awesome. The calamari was good also, I had gotten Bacon wrapped scallops also wich were good but the bacon was too charred around the scallops , needs to be a little softer.
Book a table now
I have been to Sheridan’s several times now. The food is great, the service is great, and the bartenders are great. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
We set a lunch date here with some friends and when we arrived we were told that our sweet 25lb dog was not allowed even in the wide open outdoor seating area. Very odd.
Enjoyed the pizza and they have some good beer on tap. The staff is friendly and the food is great. Great spot to have a bite and a beer.
Excellent place for wings and burgers. Nice specials as well. Always excellent drinks. Kids friendly and stuff is accomodating.
Book a table now
Overall, my waiter was awesome sauce! Loved the location and the view. Bar serviced amazing drink love this place
Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 3 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 5
