This is a very laid-back spot with a good selection of beers on tap. Jeanette (hope I spelled her name correctly) was incredibly accommodating and engaging. I tried the New York-style pizza and the Grandma's Wise Guy. The New York-style had amazing flavor, a great combination of toppings, and a satisfying crunch from tip to crust. It also had a nice char. The Grandma's Wise Guy featured a fantastic mix of two different sausages, one of which might have been fennel—absolutely delicious! The sweet sauce, drizzled with olive oil and red pepper flakes, created a perfect balance. It felt like a delightful battle of pizza sauces happening in my mouth! I enjoyed it all with a pint of Laughing Monk...
Delicious pizza by the slice or whole pie. Solid tap list as well with beers you don’t necessarily see every place. There is a by the slice counter when you walk in and that means you can get food fairly fast as they just bring those slices back up to temp or you can have a full dining experience in their cozy seating area or outside.Parking: Free parking PTO right in front andLots of metered parking on the streetWheelchair accessibility: Handicapped spot on parking lot and wide flat entrance
The pizzas are incredible, and they have a fantastic selection of craft beer. The staff is extremely friendly and helpful. While the atmosphere could use some improvement, it seems that takeout is their primary focus, and they were doing very well with it.
I really enjoy the toppings, but I've tried several different crusts and styles, and the crust is consistently quite tough. I have strong teeth, but it feels like a workout to chew through it.
Book a table now
I ordered the SIC Combo Americano twice in a row! It's excellent, fresh, and consistently great. The side of hot honey was tasty, but not spicy enough for my liking.
The pizza was definitely the best in San Leandro! It was incredibly delicious. I tried the Hot Honey flavor, and it was fantastic! Plus, the prices are great too.
This is by far my favorite pizza! I've never been a huge fan of pizza, but now I'm hooked—no exaggeration! It's delicious and definitely worth the price.
Love this pizza. We usually get the thin crust pizza. We try to eat here once a month. It's worth the 30 to 40 minute drive!
Book a table now
The wiseguy pizza was amazing! The sausage is perfectly seasoned and the spicy oil is a perfect finish
Pick-up was quick and easy. Pepperoni had a kick to it. Nice slight char on the crust. Delicious.
