Smithtown Bagels - Table reservation

Edit Mar 2022: I happened to give the store a second chance, and the owner personally pulled me aside and told me he rectified the situation and the employee no longer works there. Old Review: This used to be one of the best bagel places around. I used to visit at least once a week for years prior to the pandemic. This week I went there twice. Once, I ordered a medium coffee and it was only half filled. The second time the new girl was rude. If that's how you want to start off your morning, good luck.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

The bagels here are always fresh and the coffee is great. The counter staff is always beautiful and attentive. There is ALWAYS a line out of the door every time I am here, that is a testimony to the quality of food and the kindness of staff. The owner works hard to ensure that everything runs smoothly and they do a great task to keep up with the weekend and vacation haste! I moved from NY and get a frequent delivery from Bagels to Texas and all here loves them too!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

I moved here 3 years ago and come here several times a week. Great service! Great food and most importantly an AWESOME staff! Every staff member knows you by name and always ask about everyday life as they do with most customers who come in. My entire family (not local) loves the bagels here so every holiday for the past 3 years has been breakfast on me. LOL

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

I had two eggs fried sausage mozzarella on a whole wheat battle. It was in a contemporary fashion and it was very tasty. Going coffee was also very good and needed this morning. I'll keep this place on my radar.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Absolutely by far the best egg bagel in all surrounding cities, puts 24 hours bagels and brendalls to shame! Light and fluffy and crispy, if not chew and juicy as competition

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply