Steve's Sizzling Steaks

620 State RT 17,NJ 07072-1747, United States, Carlstadt Reservation
4 /5
6199 Reviews

"Food and service was amazing. Had a wonderful time, and will return again."

Details

Phone: +12014389677

Address: 620 State RT 17,NJ 07072-1747, United States, Carlstadt

Reservation, Booking

City: Carlstadt

Website: http://www.steves-sizzling-steaks.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:30 -21:00

Tuesday: 11:30 -21:00

Wednesday: 11:30 -21:00

Thursday: 11:30 -21:00

Friday: 11:30 -21:00

Saturday: 11:30 -21:00

Sunday: 11:30 -21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 6199


Address

Show Map

Reviews

swissguyflying

2/5

We came on recommendation from an Uber driver, who said that it was the best steak/value in the area. We trusted him and came to try it out. It was disappointing and we will not return there. Here 's why: 1. When you enter the restaurant, there is a persistent grilled onion/burned smell. 2. It 's very dark, and not much airflow, so the smell remains very persistent. 3. We ordered the filet mignon which is served with their signature sizzling plate, fries, onions and mushrooms. Somehow everything just tasted the same because it was all bathing in that onion based marinade. The meat was tender but really wouldn 't deserve a prize for its ' flavours. 4. For the quality of meat, the way its ' se...

Tricia

1/5

So here is how the experience went at this steakhouse . Our food comes out. My husband orders the ribeye medium rare and it 's well done. The waitress takes it back, leaves my food, and 15 minutes later comes back with another steak. My husband cuts into that one and it 's purple inside and still cold. Now I am done eating and he has not eaten. The waitress takes it off the bill. We are leaving and ask the hostess to speak to a manager and told one is not there. I proceeded to call the next day and was told the manager would be in later that day. I called back that and they are still not there. I called twice more than two days and finally get the manager on the phone. He said the cook has b...

Don

4/5

I went there earlier this evening for a friends birthday dinner. This was my first time there. We both ordered New York Strip steaks. I do admit the steak was superbly cooked and was a nice size. A little pricey at $36 each. But delicious!! The only thing that turned me off was the steak fries on top of the steak!!! I would have preferred a separate bowl for them andhave the steak visible with a nice garnish. It was a little frustrating moving the fries off the steak and have them fall ontothe table. The steak was so filling I actually left half of the fries!! Was stuffed!!

Libinski

4/5

Great local steak place with lots of history! Very unique, either the interior decoration, which we loved, and the way they made steak. Ribeye was good, but all steaks were too well done for medium rare order. The meat quality was not great. Overall visiting the place was a super fun experience! Book a table now

Chris

4/5

Would not call this a steak house by any stretch of the word. You come here knowing your getting a steak at an un beatable price, and you get what you paid for. Great for family, friends, sports watching, and pre-gaming before a night on the town

Lisa

2/5

We have been coming here for a very long time but unfortunately they are priced to high for a Steak and alot if frenchfries, River Palm white table cloth prices

Charlotte

4/5

For the price of the steak dinner (which was delicious), I was surprised that it was served with steak fries and about 3 mushrooms.

erik

5/5

Great food great service....! What more can you ask for!!!! Been going their every now and then for 35 years! Book a table now

Prophet

1/5

was very disappointed Service was very unprofessional and the food is not what it used to be


Dishes

Mary's Special - Ten Ounce Burger Patty With Fried Onions
Mary's Special - Ten Ounce Burger Patty With Fried Onions

Filet Mignon Tips & Five Grilled Or Blackened Shrimp
Filet Mignon Tips & Five Grilled Or Blackened Shrimp

Grilled Or Blackened Shrimp Salad (Five Shrimp)
Grilled Or Blackened Shrimp Salad (Five Shrimp)

Certified Angus Prime New York Strip (14 Ounce)
Certified Angus Prime New York Strip (14 Ounce)

Steamed Fresh Broccoli (Plain Or With Butter)
Steamed Fresh Broccoli (Plain Or With Butter)

Breaded Fried Buffalo Shrimp With Bleu Cheese
Breaded Fried Buffalo Shrimp With Bleu Cheese

Fried Zucchini Sticks With Horseradish Dijon
Fried Zucchini Sticks With Horseradish Dijon

Cowboy (Bone-In) Pork Chop With Hot Peppers
Cowboy (Bone-In) Pork Chop With Hot Peppers

1/4 Lb Hamburger (Served With Steak Fries)
1/4 Lb Hamburger (Served With Steak Fries)

Breaded Fried Shrimp With Cocktail Sauce
Breaded Fried Shrimp With Cocktail Sauce