Stuff-a-bagel

Stuff-a-bagel - Table reservation

425 Montauk Hwy, 11795, West Islip, US, United States Reservation
3.3 /5
134 Reviews

"Great egg sandwich"

Details

Phone: (+1)6316617646

Address: 425 Montauk Hwy, 11795, West Islip, US, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: West Islip

Website: https://www.stuffabagelwestislip.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 05:00 -14:00

Tuesday: 05:00 -14:00

Wednesday: 05:00 -14:00

Thursday: 05:00 -14:00

Friday: 05:00 -14:00

Saturday: 05:00 -14:00

Sunday: 05:00 -14:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 134


Address

Show Map

Reviews

User

2/5

I recently ordered a sausage, mozzarella, and tomato omelette, but received a mozzarella and tomato omelette instead. Today, I ordered a speck bagel but received a different kind of bagel. It seems that the staff processing orders are not paying attention to detail. The restaurant was not busy when I was there, but the service was slow and the area was not very clean. I usually visit at 6:30 a.m. before work on weekends, but I won't be returning after this experience.

User

5/5

So. My husband and I used to go to this bagel place in Udall Rd, we were always having some kind of problem with our order, then we decided to go to stuff a bagel and wow! The bagels are amazing, crunchy outside and soft inside, and the egg sandwiches are the best. Not to mention they’re costumer service is warm and kind. So we are definitely not going back to the other place.

User

5/5

So. My husband and I used to go to this bagel place in Udall Rd, we were always having some kind of problem with our order, then we decided to go to stuff a bagel and wow! The bagels are amazing, crunchy outside and soft inside, and the egg sandwiches are the best. Not to mention they’re costumer service is warm and kind. So we are definitely not going back to the other place.

User

1/5

Place has gone downhill and prices are really getting ridiculous. I bought a bagel and it almost broke my tooth the bagel was so freaking hard. You definitely lost another customer. GOOD LUCK ? ? ? Book a table now

Agustina

5/5

Great spot for bagels and really good cream cheese. Not the spot if you’re looking for a specialty coffee but they’ve got all the staples. We grabbed a bit of lox too and that was excellent.

User

1/5

I purchased a bagel with butter for $2.75 and received change back of $1.73. This was a great deal, thank you for that.

User

5/5

Amazing bagels! the toasted bagels with butter are amazing. The way the butter melts makes the bagel taste better.

User

5/5

the new management is wonderful! it's very clean. very friendly staff. Bagels are always good! No complaining. Book a table now

User

4/5

This restaurant offers consistently delicious bagels, decent coffee, and a great variety of cream cheeses.


Dishes

Roast Beef And Mozzarella Specialty Sandwich
Roast Beef And Mozzarella Specialty Sandwich

Pastrami And Swiss Melt Specialty Sandwich
Pastrami And Swiss Melt Specialty Sandwich

Turkey And Swiss Melt Specialty Sandwich
Turkey And Swiss Melt Specialty Sandwich

Ham And Swiss Melt Specialty Sandwich
Ham And Swiss Melt Specialty Sandwich

Cracked Peppermill Turkey Sandwich
Cracked Peppermill Turkey Sandwich

The Amazing Met Specialty Sandwich
The Amazing Met Specialty Sandwich

Turkey Supreme Specialty Sandwich
Turkey Supreme Specialty Sandwich

Bronx Bomber Specialty Sandwich
Bronx Bomber Specialty Sandwich

Egg Whites And Turkey Sandwich
Egg Whites And Turkey Sandwich

Bologna And American Sandwich
Bologna And American Sandwich