I wish I could give zero stars. As a local Bethpage resident and longtime regular, I will never step foot in Stuff A Bagel again. They have a sign stating a minimum purchase is required to use a credit card, even though this is against New York State and federal law. Credit card fees are a percentage of the total, so charging under $10 shouldn't cost more. On Father's Day at 7:30 a.m., I was alone on my way to work and just wanted a bagel and a Yoo-Hoo, totaling $5.33. The cashier pointed out the $10 minimum, so I added another Yoo-Hoo, bringing it to about $7. I didn’t want anything else. I asked the manager if they could make an exception—an emphatic no. I get that bagel shops might not be...
Great food. The ham- -Swiss melt on egg bagel (w/garlic butter was amazing. However, one-star off for no spoon provided with yogurt parfait. (Thank goodness there was enough body with the granola to scoop out up — awkwardly — with a fork. Another point off for the sliced watermelon: It was abominable, and I ended up just chucking it after a couple samplings. Food: 5 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3
Best bagels in bethpage. My personal fav is Egg bagel. Staff is extremely helpful and friendly. They are very fast and efficient with the ordering process. I’be never had to wait too long for an order, and they consistently get my order correct. I’m a Bethpage local, and I love this place. I’ll always be a return customer
I walk in every morning and the staff knows exactly what I want WITHOUT me having to say a word, except, GOOD MORNING! Thank you Lisa, Oscar, Randi, Ana, Jose and all!!
Book a table now
Stuff A Bagel is our go-to local spot for bagels, and we visit at least once a week for breakfast. The menu offers tasty options that are both delicious and convenient.
Food was very tasty, definitely will come back for more! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
My favorite spot for breakfast and the occasional lunch. Excellent menu, affordable prices, and friendly staff!
had an awesome omelet from here very surprised on the omelet not burnt and ingredients were fresh
Book a table now
Always good food! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Service: Takeaway Price per person: $10–20
Credit card minimum makes its so you have to spend 10$ on breakfast a day
Belgian Waffle With Fresh Fruit And Whipped Cream
Sausage Patty 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese On A Bagel
Sausage Patty 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese On A Roll
Ham Bacon Sausage 2 Eggs And Cheese On A Bagel
Ham Bacon Sausage 2 Eggs And Cheese On A Roll
Our Signature Croissant Stuffed French Toast
3 Egg Whites Turkey And Cheese On A Bagel
Bacon 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese On A Bagel
3 Egg Whites Turkey And Cheese On A Roll
Bacon 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese On A Roll
