Pizza Place

Pizza Place - Table reservation

18 Marshall Hill Rd, 07480, West Milford, US, 07480-2123, United States Reservation
4 /5
636 Reviews

"The pizza is fantastic, and I'm a big fan of their Philly cheesesteaks!"

Details

Phone: +19737282228,+19737282539

Address: 18 Marshall Hill Rd, 07480, West Milford, US, 07480-2123, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: West Milford

Website: http://www.tjsmenu.com

Opening hours

Monday: 11:00-21:30

Tuesday: 11:00-21:30

Wednesday: 11:00-21:30

Thursday: 11:00-21:30

Friday: 11:00-21:30

Saturday: 11:00-21:30

Sunday: 11:00-21:30

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 636


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Pizza

4/5

First up was the Margherita pie. The dough was very fresh and slightly thick, which was nice. However, the unusual part was that, while it featured fresh mozzarella, basil, and drops of plum tomato sauce, it was served over a traditional pizza base. This meant that the Margherita toppings were placed on a regular pie with standard mozzarella and sauce underneath. So, it wasn't a true Margherita pizza, but we still appreciated the overall flavor and the use of fresh ingredients that elevated the basic pie. Next, we tried the Brooklyn Square, which is quite similar to a Grandma pie, and it was the best of the three! It had a thick square crust and was incredibly fresh. The mozzarella cheese w...

Louis

5/5

I can 't get over how great the food is here. The two available soups were homemade and some of the best I 've ever tasted. The menu is way beyond what a pizza joint normally offers. The seating is limited so a good portion of their business is take-out. I 've had dinners and heroes to date; no pizza yet. Had a scrumptious shrimp parmigiana hero tonight. Summation: great food and great service from a family owned business.

Soraida

3/5

The salad was fantastic; I enjoyed the spicy peppers added to my garden salad, which was a pleasant surprise. I ordered the chicken piccata, and it was very good. However, my side of spaghetti with marinara sauce was disappointing—it tasted like something you'd find in a low-quality jarred sauce, which wasn't appealing at all. It’s a shame because making marinara sauce from scratch is quite simple.

Nicola

3/5

I placed an order for the family combo. Was expecting it to be what I paid for. Turns out I got skimped. I asked for 12 BBQ wings and I was highly disappointed with how they arrived. There is barely any sauce on these. The totally was $36 almost $40. Not to mention, I ordered this for delivery, it took over an hour to arrive. Unacceptable. Never coming here again. Book a table now

MARITZA

5/5

Incredible service, delicious food, and the owners are really kind! The meals are fantastic, and they accommodate your preferences perfectly. My personal favorite is the penne a la vodka with chicken. I always request extra veggies, and they add just the right amount. I highly recommend this restaurant!

KitKat

5/5

Found this gem of a place over covid 2020 shut down ... and to this this day they are just amazing .... this eggplant spinach panini is my go to after 3 years!!! Love this place and the staff is awesome

MELISSA

5/5

Absolutely amazing homemade soups and delicious food! The delivery is always quick, and the staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming!

Caiden

5/5

What can I say it's TJ's. Absolutely amazing service with the owners and workers being extremely nice. Amazing pizza and fast service. Book a table now

Kimberly

5/5

We absolutely love TJs; it's definitely our top choice for pizza and Italian cuisine.


Dishes

Parmesan Asparagus
Parmesan Asparagus

Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers

Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Chicken

Boneless Wings
Boneless Wings

Garden Salad
Garden Salad

Chicken Parm
Chicken Parm

Tomato Cream Soup
Tomato Cream Soup

Cuban Sandwich
Cuban Sandwich

Bbq Wings
Bbq Wings