Tomato Pie

Tomato Pie - Table reservation

5301 Division Ave S, 49548, Wyoming, US, United States Reservation
4.7 /5
1220 Reviews

"$21 got us a 4 topping 12 pizza and garlic bread. I liked everything about it. Perfection -Rachael"

Details

Phone: +16166083576

Address: 5301 Division Ave S, 49548, Wyoming, US, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Wyoming

Website: https://tomatopiegr.com

Opening hours

Tuesday: 11:00-17:00

Wednesday: 11:00-19:00

Thursday: 11:00-19:00

Friday: 11:00-19:00

Saturday: 16:00-20:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1220


Address

Show Map

Reviews

User

2/5

Unfortunately, when our pizzas did arrive, we found that the plain cheese pizza was undercooked, with a nearly translucent crust and a strange acidic taste. It seemed like the dough was old or had too much yeast. My companion ended up having to throw his pizza away, which is something we had never experienced before. One person in our group did enjoy their pizza, noting that the cheese and sauce were good. Personally, I would consider returning to this restaurant if they address their issues with consistency, cook the pizzas more thoroughly, and respect their customers' time by providing accurate wait times upfront before taking payment.

User

5/5

WOW!!!Ok, so my husband's friends threw him a diaper party and needed some pizza to accompany their evening. I was playing chauffeur from one location to the next and stuck around to try out this this pizza. Wow. It was so so good. We had everything from the usual Pepperoni to a bbq chicken one with jalapenos and banana peppers... AMAZING. I think we had like 15 total including the incredible cheesy bread with garlic butter dipping sauce (that I could seriously put on everything, or just drink...don't judge I couldn't stop trying all of them and none of them disappointed. We will absolutely be getting these again!

User

5/5

I highly recommend the pizza at this restaurant! The dough is excellent and the toppings all seemed to be of high quality. The pizza oven is fantastic and cooks the pizza in just a few minutes. The service was fast and friendly, able to accommodate our pick-up order quickly. The hot BBQ chicken pizza was delicious. In fact, it was difficult to choose which pizza to order because they all sounded fantastic. I wish we had ordered more than one!

User

5/5

Pizza was delicious! The tre fomaggio was outstanding with the homemade garlic sauce. Homemade red sauce was on point. All ingredients were fresh as well as made right in front of you. Building was very clean including the restrooms. The customer service was top notch, super friendly and personable. Highly recommend Book a table now

User

5/5

Outstanding pizza joint! Top to bottom; from the aesthetics of the place,the original Italian wood fire oven,their menu(they offer Faygo products to their homemade sauce,and dough. This place has it all. Give Kintea and company a call,the next time you're in the mood for a real pie.Bravo

User

5/5

Best artisan pizza around! The dough and sauce is exquisite. Todd made my wife and I a pizza and it was outstanding!!! I’m a big fan of the sausage! The pizza oven is so cool and it was very tidy and clean. Will definitely be back!!

User

4/5

friendly staff, relaxing dining area, eating was simply amazing, they see the sub / pizza made right in front of you. the ruined sausage was delicious and well portioned, that is one must try when they are in the opposite!

User

5/5

I tried the $8 lunch special and the pizza was amazing. It was probably the most delicious wood-fired pizza I have ever tasted. I will definitely be returning! Book a table now

User

5/5

Absolutely Delicious! Owner and staff are very personable and friendly... great experience!Make your own pizza option too!

User

5/5

$21 got us a 4 topping 12 pizza and garlic bread. I liked everything about it. Perfection -Rachael


Dishes

Pastrami Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich

Bbq Chicken Pizza
Bbq Chicken Pizza

Blue Cheese Salad
Blue Cheese Salad

Vegetarian Pizza
Vegetarian Pizza

Pizza Margherita
Pizza Margherita

Grilled Chicken
Grilled Chicken

Hawaiian Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza

Pesto Chicken
Pesto Chicken

Pastrami Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich

Italian Pizza
Italian Pizza