Uncle Bacala's

Uncle Bacala's - Table reservation

2370 Jericho Tpke, 11040, New Hyde Park, United States Reservation
4.6 /5
1413 Reviews

"I visited this restaurant for the first time and the food is incredible. The service is outstanding too—be sure to ask for Harmen; he is the best waiter you’ll find!"

Details

Phone: +15167390505

Address: 2370 Jericho Tpke, 11040, New Hyde Park, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: New Hyde Park

Website: https://www.unclebacala.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:30-21:40

Tuesday: 11:30-21:40

Wednesday: 11:30-21:40

Thursday: 11:30-21:40

Friday: 11:30-22:40

Saturday: 11:30-22:40

Sunday: 12:00-21:40

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1413


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Eklea

2/5

I was quite disappointed to discover a 3.5% fee for paying with a credit card. It's frustrating that customers are penalized for using a payment method that the restaurant accepts. While the restaurant itself is beautiful and the service was excellent, the overall experience didn't quite match my previous visits. I noticed that some menu prices had increased, but the menu hadn’t been updated to reflect these changes. Although the portion sizes were generous, the salmon I ordered didn’t taste right, and the vegetables were bland—I could hardly tell the eggplant from the zucchini. On a positive note, the squid ink spaghetti was amazing! I also appreciated the nice touch of having cotton candy...

User

3/5

I was very disappointed to find that I was charged a 3.5% fee for paying with a credit card. It feels unfair to penalize customers for using credit. The restaurant itself is nice, and the service was excellent, but the food didn't meet the quality I remember from my previous visits. I noticed some menu prices have increased, but the menu hasn’t been updated to reflect those changes. While the portions are generous, the salmon I ordered lacked flavor, and the vegetables, especially the zucchini, didn’t taste right either. However, the ink cream dish was fantastic! I also appreciated the cotton candy served at the end.

David

5/5

We were a family of 16 dining outdoors, and everything from the appetizers to the main course was absolutely delicious. My own dish, the Filet Mignon with gorgonzola cheese and mushrooms in a cognac reduction, was the best I've ever tasted. The service was prompt and attentive, and most importantly, the dishes were served hot! You won't be disappointed here.

User

5/5

Hosted a baby shower in the back room, great experience. One downside we smelled the gasoline from the outside heaters in the room, so would recommend to tell the restaurant to make sure the heaters aren?t near the windows! We had one main server for about 40 people and they did a great job. Would def go back again for a regular meal! Book a table now

Jesse

5/5

This was my first visit back after a three-month hiatus, and I can confidently say it was well worth the wait. Like many loyal patrons, I've been excited to return following their unfortunate kitchen fire that caused a temporary closure. The food is as incredible as always, and I'm delighted to see them back in operation.

Rhodora

5/5

Uncle Bacala's food is consistently excellent. Hats off to the chef and management! The Chicken Marsala made with fresh ingredients is incredibly delicious and comforting. The salmon is outstanding, and the calamari is perfectly crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Truly commendable!

Rhodora

5/5

The Chicken Marsala is absolutely delicious, with incredible flavors! The Chicken Caesar Salad is fresh and delightful. The calamari is perfect—crispy on the outside yet tender on the inside. Hats off to the chef! Thank you for a wonderful meal.

User

5/5

Stopped in looking for a place to eat in the area, and was totally satisfied I did. Great food fabulous portions, you can't leave there not full and satisfied. Nice friendly service comfortable atmosphere. Found a new spot Book a table now

User

5/5

Awesome place. Went to celebrate my aunt and uncle's anniversary, food was awesome, drinks, esp coconut martini, was so good had to order 2! Service was awesome, will Def come back!

User

5/5

I visited this restaurant for the first time and the food is incredible. The service is outstanding too—be sure to ask for Harmen; he is the best waiter you’ll find!


Dishes

Family Style Romaine And Baby Arugula Salad
Family Style Romaine And Baby Arugula Salad

Family Style Whole Wheat Linguini Di Pesce
Family Style Whole Wheat Linguini Di Pesce

Family Style Penne Or Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Family Style Penne Or Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Family Style Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare
Family Style Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare

Family Style Homemade Fresh Bacala Salad
Family Style Homemade Fresh Bacala Salad

Regular Romaine And Baby Arugula Salad
Regular Romaine And Baby Arugula Salad

Regular Whole Wheat Linguini Di Pesce
Regular Whole Wheat Linguini Di Pesce

Family Style Linguini Con Le Vongole
Family Style Linguini Con Le Vongole

Family Style Spaghetti And Meatballs
Family Style Spaghetti And Meatballs

Family Style Mixed Greens Side Salad
Family Style Mixed Greens Side Salad