Caution advised... The only positive aspect of my visit was the kindness of the waitress. However, after ordering, I noticed roaches crawling around. When I brought this to the waitress's attention, she informed me that they were aware of the problem. She mentioned that they had been cleaning the restaurant themselves because the owner couldn't afford professional cleaners. When I spoke with the owner about the roach issue, I saw that roaches were crawling into the pizza boxes he was holding. They really need to replace the dirty carpet and booths. A professional cleaning and extermination service is necessary to address the problem effectively.
The food at Valentino's Pizzeria is fantastic! The new owners have completely redesigned the menu, and I’m excited to see the renovations they have in store. The staff is incredibly friendly, but the true highlight is definitely the delicious food. Their catering service is the most seamless I’ve experienced so far. The location is excellent, especially given the high standards and competition for pizza on Long Island. Kid-friendliness: Very family-oriented. Parking: Large parking lot available.
I stopped by the other night with my friend (I was wearing baby blue shorts, a t-shirt, and a hat). We experienced fast and friendly service, and the food was great—perfect for a quick bite before getting back to our busy day. The adorable counter girl with her bright smile was just a lovely bonus! Follow me on Instagram @mike_mercerx.
Terribly disappointing! The dough was soggy, and the sauce had an unpleasant taste. I ordered a chicken parmesan slice, but the chicken was rubbery, and the slice fell apart. No one was wearing gloves, and the guy behind the counter was outside smoking before coming back in and serving customers without washing his hands!
Book a table now
**Vegetarian options:** Salad pizza is available.
**Dietary restrictions:** They offer a wide variety of pizza options to accommodate different needs.
**Parking:** There's plenty of parking space.
**Kid-friendliness:** Very kid-friendly!
**Wheelchair accessibility:** Yes, it's accessible for wheelchairs.
Since the new owners took over, Valentino’s Pizzeria has become my family’s favorite place for pizza and Italian cuisine. Being a family-run business, the restaurant has a cozy, homey feel. The food is tasty, portions are plentiful, and the ambiance is inviting. Valentino’s always delivers!
Wow! I was so impressed with the pizza and service! I am pizza snob and have been to Valentino’s before because I live in the area and I could take it or leave it…. but these NEW OWNERS KNOCKED IT OUT OF THE PARK! You have a customer for life!
Everything we've tried at Valentino’s Pizzeria has been fantastic! The meatballs are incredible—just like homemade by my grandma. The pizza is always perfectly cooked. Highly recommended!
Book a table now
This restaurant is fantastic! The food is delicious, and the staff are exceptional. I highly recommend dining in or ordering takeout—you won’t be disappointed!
We had them cater a party for us, and the food was fantastic! The sub was the best I've had in years. I'm really looking forward to using their services again.
