Vintage Pizzeria

Vintage Pizzeria - Table reservation

5434 Peachtree Rd Atlanta, GA 30341, United States Reservation
4.2 /5
2177 Reviews

"Food is good NY style pizza Staff not very welcoming"

Details

Phone: +16786460400

Address: 5434 Peachtree Rd Atlanta, GA 30341, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Atlanta

Website: https://www.vintagepizzeria.com/

Opening hours

Tuesday: 11:30 -21:00

Wednesday: 11:30 -21:00

Thursday: 11:30 -21:00

Friday: 11:30 -21:00

Saturday: 12:00-21:00

Sunday: 04:00-21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 2177


Address

Show Map

Reviews

McKenna

4/5

I've only had takeout, but this pizza is delicious. Crust is super thin, which makes it a bit floppy in the middle but the flavor of the sauce and cheese make up for it. Might order a pie well done next time. That's also just my personal preference, I like a bit more crunch. I've tried over 20 different pizza places in and outside ATL and this is one of the best, in the top 5 for sure. The inside is also really cool and would be great for anyone, families, couples, etc.I'll be picking up a pizza from here anytime I'm in the Chamblee area!

McKenna

5/5

I rarely give rewiew but I've got to give a 5 star here. My husband wanted to come here because hes always loved the lunch special. We came in tonight around 5 pm. Really good service. Great food. However I wasn't really a fan of the calamari I ordered as a main dish. No problem! They swapped it out for a GIANT and delicious side of fettuccine Alfredo. His spaghetti with meat sauce was so good, as was the salad and soup. We also had a really good chocolate cake! We willdefinitely be back! Also drinks were refilled very quickly :

McKenna

4/5

The cheesy garlic bread is a cheese lover's dream! Didn't care much for the calamari it was overcooked/dry and the breading appeared to be cornmeal ? the okra that came with it was good, though. My friend liked the pizza and caesar salad. Outdoor seating was a plus. Ample seating indoors with a decent sized bar. Friendly/attentive staff. Small parking lot directly outside front doors with an overflow lot to the right. Bonus: the Frosty Caboose is directly across thestreet we grabbed an ice cream cone after dinner!

Jess

5/5

Cannot recommend enough! My coworker and I stumbled across this gem because of the close proximity to our office and we make a point to go once a week for lunch. They have great lunch specials, I tell all my friends and coworkers about their soups. The staff is consistent, and so friendly and laid back. All the food is so fresh and delicious. Book a table now

McKenna

3/5

Decent spot to get pizza and a salad. I got the large Greek salad. It was good, but not quite Mellow Mushroom level. The pizza is good. I wish you could order a slice for dinner and not just lunch! They have trivia on Thursdays. I wouldn?t go out of my way to eat here, but I?ll probably be back.

McKenna

5/5

This is, hands down, the best spot to grab a slice in Chamblee. Fantastic atmosphere, very well-run bar, excellent ny style pizza with a world class greek salad. And the general manager, Richard, is an absolute rockstar and the service is top notch. Couldn?t recommend it more.

JeffJ

5/5

Our last visit to vintage pizza was probably the best we've ever had, I didn't remember the name of the waitress but she was amazing, next time we're just going to have to stand around and I'm going to point to her where are her tables?

Harrison

5/5

We love it here! Meatballs are amazing. Sauce has a little zing that sets it apart. You can have dogs on the covered patio and walk across the street to get ice cream at the red caboose. Book a table now

Juan

4/5

Is the second time I visit, this time I had the chicken Parm sandwich, it was good. Previously, I had their pizza by the slice and liked it a lot.


Dishes

New York Style Cheesecake
New York Style Cheesecake

Kids Meatball Slider Fries
Kids Meatball Slider Fries

Seven Layer Chocolate Cake
Seven Layer Chocolate Cake

Kids Chicken Fingers Fries
Kids Chicken Fingers Fries

Kids Grilled Cheese Fries
Kids Grilled Cheese Fries

Spaghetti Bolognese Pasta
Spaghetti Bolognese Pasta

Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta
Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta

Slice Carmen's Own Pizza
Slice Carmen's Own Pizza

Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Mozzarella Sticks

Eggplant Parmesan Pasta
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta