I'm not sure what's going on with this place lately. Since it changed its name, I've been there twice (for takeout), and both times my order has been messed up. The first time, I ordered a cowboy burger but only received a plain burger. The second time, I ordered the crushed brisket tacos and didn't get the avocado salsa. Based on previous reviews, it seems like this is a common issue. The food is good, but be sure to double-check your order. It's disappointing because you'd hope they would improve their accuracy.
Calling them a disgrace would be a compliment. I have asked for mayonnaise on the side of my burger on multiple occasions and they ignore the instructions every single time! A cheap establishment that has staff that could not care less. Put some heart into your food! Pathetic. Side note, not sure what made you think I would enjoy this nasty piece of tomato in my pasta. A 6 year old would have done a better job.
The food at this restaurant is good, and we generally found the wait staff to be attentive. However, during our last few visits, the sangria I ordered was quite disappointing—watery and flavorless. For the price I paid, it shouldn't have tasted like Kool-Aid. Additionally, I found the name change to VINTAGE TAVERN to be odd; why alter a name that was already good?
Chimney rock is a classic Berkeley Heights diner and every middle schooler growing up knows about it. I tried it for the first time recently and it was pretty good. The portions are generous and the dishes taste good. 4 stars. These dishes are definitely not meant to taste beyond what people can make at home.
Book a table now
Can't complain about our server. She felt really bad. We waited for 2 1/2 hours for 2 pizzas. Appetizers came 1 at a time after we asked 3 or 4 times for them. Server had to take one of the cakes from the site. It was cold. In the middle of the meal we were asked if we wanted to go the pizza. Not back.
It was called Chimney Rock and rebranded. They also changed the pizza and the crust is now clearly not handmade it tastes like a flat bread cracker and is factory cut into perfect circles. The fries are different. I liked the old menu better. This was our favorite pizza spot for years.
We sat in the bar to play Trivia. Our server was bubbly and attentive; it ensured that we were never thirsty. My Quesadilla was delicious, and the pizza of my table was also. Margarita was good, decent beer selection.
They failed to send my pizza, and when I called and told them, they said they had nobody to deliver it, so I didn't get it. The pierogis were fine but a small portion 4 pieces. Very disappointing experience.
Book a table now
Consistently excellent and delicious—the best in the area! I've never encountered any issues with their gluten-free options.
Delicious pizza and beer! The tavern-style decor and ambiance create a welcoming vibe. It's an ideal spot for large groups.
Homemade Classic French Onion Soup
Pan Seared Chicken Parmigiana
Nashville Hot Crispy Chicken
Honey Sriracha Chicken Pizza
Chipotle Chicken Quesadilla
Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
Ribeye Philly Cheesesteak
