Tried a regular pie and a tavern pie after reading the reviews here and on Google . Regular Pie: Have to be honest- it's good and it blows the local competition away but that's not saying much when you consider the competition in my humble opinion. Odds are if you've been a fan of DeMarco's or Suzie's for years and years then this place isn't going to make you jump for joy. If you are like me and get frustrated in a search for something that resembles a legit NY pie then you'll be happy with the regular pizza here as compared to the rest of the area (Warwick included) AMENDED: Tavern Pie: Again, I'm someone who is all about the thin and crispy pizza/brick oven pies (and not because Bar Stool...
We have had pizza from here previously and thoroughly enjoyed it. Owner is very friendly. A bit disappointed this evening as I went there to quickly buy a chicken parm hero. The length of the sub was at least 12 inches. The contents didn't thrill so much. The chicken was paper thin and the bread overwhelmed the meat. The breading top and bottom was thicker than the chicken
I still believe this is the best new pizzeria in the area. I just ordered a pizza through the Slice app, and the delivery was prompt and within the estimated time frame. The pizza once again featured a deliciously fresh, thin, and light crust with fantastic flavor and a great distribution of toppings! I highly recommend it.
My regular pizza place was closed so I took a chance on Antonio's. I ordered a pizza within 25 mins my pizza arrived as promised by a smiling young lady. I normally prefer a thicker crust but it didn't matter. Pizza was outstanding .... Antonio's is now my regular place. Totally worth ever cent !!!
Book a table now
The pizza comes with everything stacked on it collapsing the top, supposed to be no pasta with the chicken dish so that was garbage because of a physical ailment, the salad was HOT ...strike 2. I figured the first order was just a bad day now this is a 2 for 2 failure
We love ordering here! Cesar is phenomenal and always goes above and beyond to make sure we are taken care of. They have just about everything on the menu you could think of. I promise you there is something for everyone in the family.
We are new to the area and we're delighted to have found this wonderful spot. Ingredients were super fresh, particularly the over the top broccoli rabe! Service was ok, and pizza was made to order and obviously fresh.
I really enjoy this restaurant; they serve fantastic pizza, and I particularly love their salads and paninis. The staff is friendly, and the prices are very reasonable.
Book a table now
So happy I discovered them today, pizza ingredients tasted fresh and the overall quality was impressive for the price. Will definitely order again.
Delicious food and excellent service. This has become my new favorite pizza spot in West Milford!
