Welcome to The Nightmare Deli, where October is filled with more tricks than treats. I placed an order yesterday and, when I went to pick it up today, it was completely wrong. Instead of resolving the issue, the clerk was rude, disrespectful, and confrontational. He actually said, "Oh, you should've been more specific. We have nothing written down, which means nothing was specified." How much clearer can you be when ordering plain sandwiches with cheese? Atlantic Deli, I've written a eulogy for you as I prepare to say goodbye. Thank you for over 15 years of service; you were once exceptional at your craft. My grandfather catered from you for all his special occasions. Sadly, you’ve really de...
Stopped in when we were traveling, and oh my goodness, they were wonderful. They were kind, and helpful, and the coffee was amazing! They made us breakfast sandwiches in 3 minutes flat, and we also got wraps for later on, that were just amazing. I would eat here every single day, if I lived in the neighborhood! Folks who live nearby are blessed! Yum!
When Atlantic Deli gets your order right, it's quite good; unfortunately, they often have issues with accuracy. I've been going there for the past 5-6 years, and ordering over the phone is always a gamble. Sometimes, you're lucky if they even answer the phone. Bagel Dock, just around the corner, is a much better choice and is actually reliable.
I recently ordered the Beef and Bacon Hero with mayo, oil, and vinegar from Atlantic Ave Deli, and it was absolutely amazing! It perfectly satisfied my craving. The menu offers fantastic options, and I wholeheartedly recommend this spot. I enjoyed every last bite!
Book a table now
"Let's Make a Sandwich" is ideal for customizing to your personal preferences. I found my sandwich to be incredibly delicious.
Every weekend, I love having a breakfast date with my husband. The food and service at this place are the best in town!
The food was delicious and the service was quick and efficient! It's a fantastic spot for a quick meal.
Atlantic Ave Deli offers the best sandwiches on Long Island! My top pick is the bacon, egg, and cheese.
Book a table now
I thoroughly enjoyed the Roast Beef Let's Make a Sandwich and the 12oz Mixed Fruit Parfait.
The coffee sandwiches are amazing. Never disappointed when I come here!
