Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"Really amazing pizza even at 9:30 at night. Delicious!"
Phone: +15166235645
Address: 171 Atlantic Avenue, Village Of Freeport, 11520, United States Of America, Village of Freeport
Reservation, Booking
City: Village of Freeport
Monday: 10:00 -22:00
Tuesday: 10:00 -22:00
Wednesday: 10:00 -22:00
Thursday: 10:00 -22:00
Friday: 10:00 -22:00
Saturday: 10:00 -22:00
Sunday: 11:00 -22:00
Dishes: 4
Categories: 5
Reviews: 188
I seldom review pizza places, bevause everyone has their preference here in New York. Dis one 's dah best!! Nah, nah you gotta go wit dat one in BROOKLYN, untouchable!! And so goes the Italian argument; tale as old as time. That being said; I 'm taking the opportunity to let you know that Atlantic is a phenomenal spot on multiple levels. Firstly, the ambiance is unique. This isn 't something I 'd typically care about it, but they hit it out of the park with good blues music and stellar decor. The pizza is excellent top to bottom. The Spicy Spaghetti ? slice combines diced chicken cutlet, fradivalo sauce and al dente pasta under a thin layer of mozzarella. Bring your taste buds and an appetit...
This place used to be good until they hired new employees. Soggy food, making mistakes on orders, too long delivery time. I live 5 minutes away for context. I ordered a panini, they made a hero sandwich. They say they will replace it with the right order. What arrived to me was vegetables in between soggy pita bread. Since when were paninis made with pita bread… and soggy?!?! Seriously, this place used to be amazing the new employees are ruining it!!!! They dont even understand what you want!!!
The owner Frank is such a great guy. Always asking how the family is. The food is always amazing, freshly made. They have the best stuffed garlic knots, rice balls, specialty pizza pies dinners. The atmosphere in the pizzeria is warm and welcoming jazz music always playing and plenty of music memorabilia to look at. By far my favorite Italian food on Long Island
Old school Italian pizzeria. When I need my stuffed artichokes, no better place to get them. Haven't had a disappointing meal there yet. Been going for 4+ Book a table now
The Pizza and food just keeps getting better and better!!! Lentil soup is phenomenal and now the fresh bread and cookies.... forgetaboutit...
Amazing place. only down to play hockey and found this gem. will definitely come again when we play the arrows.
Simply the best how can you beat it excellent Chicken Ceasar salad and the Blues! Oh yeah those cheese knots...
everything is really good except the spinish roll was too old and could not eat was bad Book a table now
tbh i just love this pizza only place i go to literally workers are nice
