"Great bagels, and great service. Even when there is a long line, they have enough people to keep it moving quickly. Great place!"
Ah, breakfast on Long Island can be a real treat, especially since we've perfected the bagel and breakfast sandwich. Bagels by the Bay definitely lives up to the hype. I moved away from the island five years ago, and besides missing my family and friends, I often find myself longing for the delicious food I've grown up with. Whenever I visit home, I'm eager to indulge in all my favorites. If you're in the area, this casual spot is perfect for grabbing breakfast or lunch on the go, or you can choose to dine in since they have seating available. We stopped by for breakfast, and everything was fantastic. The bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll was spot-on, and the everything bagel, toasted and top...
This is my only go to spot for breakfast in sayville/oakdale, and I am shocked by the negative reviews. I love this place.This is the only establishment in the area where you can have a nice breakfast sit down breakfast platter for under 8 bucks. And the bagels are always fresh and delicious.I always get the 2 eggs, home fries, bacon, toasted bagel and OJ. Yum.The people who work here are nice and they always get the order right and have it done very quickly. I love eating here in the morning and reading the paper at the back table. It is very peaceful.It's much better than spending 20 dollars at the diner. I think that I want to work here. BTW-This place is packed in the morning so they mus...
Excellent bagels, food, coffee, and breakfast sandwiches! I’ve always had a great experience with both the food and service here. The staff is friendly, and the bagels are consistently fresh and tasty. My personal favorite is the whole-wheat sunflower seed flagel.
In town from San Diego and stopped by this joint after some disc golf. Beautiful ladies behind the counter, great customer service and the best bagel breakfast sandwich I have had, hands down! Will be back again. Check them out.
Book a table now
The bagels are excellent, the staff is incredibly friendly and treats everyone with kindness, and they have great specials, such as a complimentary coffee or hot chocolate with your bagel sandwich.
In my humble opinion, this is the best bacon, egg, and cheese (BEC) on Long Island. As someone who enjoys food, I think that carries some weight!
The bagels here are wonderfully soft and chewy, with a great selection to choose from. They really don’t hold back on the flavorful toppings!
I am not satisfied with my experience. I ordered my bacon well done, but it was only barely cooked. I'm sure the server heard my request.
Book a table now
Joann is the only reason this place is amazing!!! Makes the best of the best!! So sweet and welcoming and keeps the place clean!!
Great bagels, and great service. Even when there is a long line, they have enough people to keep it moving quickly. Great place!
