Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"Awesome bagels and flats and great service- willing and able to take on complex orders!"
Phone: +15169219773
Address: 43 Cold Spring Road, Syosset, 11791, United States Of America
Reservation, Booking
City: Syosset
Website: http://www.bagelmaster.com
Monday: 05:00 -16:00
Tuesday: 05:00 -16:00
Wednesday: 05:00 -16:00
Thursday: 05:00 -16:00
Friday: 05:00 -16:00
Saturday: 06:00 -16:00
Sunday: 06:00 -15:00
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 6238
Bagels are pretty decent but service is atrociously terrible (unless they know you well as a customer . Older white male working there (I think he might have been the owner? threw my card back on the counter instead of directly handing it back to me. He was also generally rude and impatient, walking off a lot while I was still in the middle of placing my order. Then, what do you know, he did a complete 180 with the next customer and was super friendly, asking him questions about his family and his life. Such a horrible business practice considering we are all paying customers at the end of the day smh
Layout/atmosphere *Store is attached to a pharmacy next door; couple of tables for indoor dining; own separate window for pickup orders; feel of a Jewish delicatessen with the spreads, salads, smoked fish, etc having their own window/station Service *Friendly Food/drink *Acme’s Finest (three over medium eggs, cream cheese, tomato, cucumber, and sliced nova on whole wheat everything bagel) good but messy; bagel itself was right size/texture; came with free hot chocolate (good) *Egg salad (on whole wheat everything bagel) Good *Mike’s Philly Fluff Pound Cake Good
Was out on the island for the weekend and before heading home to New Jersey I figured I get a bagel. I came upon this bagel shop and it looked busy enough so I thought it must be decent, sadly I was wrong. I ordered a Taylor ham egg and cheese and while they certainly were generous with the egg and a decent amount of cheese there was a single piece of cold deli ham on the bagel. To make matters worse the bagel tasted like it was purchased from a chain supermarket. Kept saying to myself I should've just stopped at Dunkin!
Close to home. My favorite whole wheat everything bagels . Only problem is, every time I go there, no matter how big or small the order is, it is NEVER correct! I stopped going here for a while because of this and said, let me try once more. BIG mistake, I even wrote down my order and handed it to the girl. Came home, opened everything up, not right! Yuk! Won't be back. Book a table now
I used to frequent this restaurant, but lately I have been disappointed. The prices have gone up, the wait times have gotten longer, and my orders are often not prepared as requested. East Norwich bagels have surpassed this place in my rankings. The prices are too high and the service is poor. East Norwich bagels are clearly the better choice.
We've been going to Bagel Master since, well, before the kids were born... Over the last 15 years the food has been consistently delicious, with great service. It's wonderful to see small businesses that are part of the local community survive and thrive through the years. Highly recommended!
I'm hitting them one star for completely abandoning the garlic bagel. Objectively, the best bagel flavor. I was subjected to the second-best flavor--not the Everything, please. The chicken salad was pretty good as well as the bagel.
Great place and lots to choose from, if they had prune danishes to add to their pastry selection, and garlic bagels, that would be the cherry on top. Book a table now
Great place and lots to choose from, if they prune danishes to add to their pastry selection, garlic bagels, that would be the cherry on top.
Awesome bagels and flats and great service- willing and able to take on complex orders!
