Had pizza from here for the first time. I?ve been hearing that they?re grandma pizza it?s really good. I had it yesterday and it was mad good. I had the regular slice but it wasn?t good. It was so worth it and I like what they added into the grandma sliceand it was really fancy. I don?t really go out of my way to come here but I will definitely make another stop soon but I don?tknow when that will be. I love pizza just like everyone else loves pizza but as of right now I won?t put this place in my top 10of my favorite pizza. I?m usually by the portion road area a lot but I go to other food spots in that area. The regular pizzaslice I give a 4/10 and the grandma slice I give an easy 10/10. De...
THE BEST PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND THAT I'VE DISCOVERED!!! From the first glance to the first bite, it's absolutely incredible. Both of my parents were born and raised in Italy, so they take their pizza very seriously, and I do too. The crust is so delicious, it's even better than my grandma's Pasta Fasulo. And trust me, that’s a big compliment! The way Bonny's Pizzeria prepares their pizza is simply divine—truly heavenly. The chef's skills rival those of Gordon Ramsay. So remember, everyone, when you eat, make sure you do it right!
I love their pizza its my favorite. And the wings too. But last week I order pizza and wings but the wings were so bad they were not fresh, so hard and barely had any sauce on them they tasted like they were left over or from a previously canceledorder. I figured this may have been a one time thing, so the next weekend, I go back just for the pizza, and even though it wasordered ahead of time, they said that the cook didn't receive the ticket, so I wound up waiting 45 minutes for a cheese pizzathat wasn't even fully cooked!
BEST PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND THAT I HAVE FOUND!!! From the first look to the first taste all around amazing. Both my parents born and raised Italian. They take their pizza game very serious, and don't play easy with their judgments; neither do I. The crumbson the dough are better than my grandma's Pasta Fasulo. Trust me that's a good dish, but the way that ANDIAMO'S cooks up theirpizza is divine, heavenly, and the chef is on par with Gordon Ramsey. Grace and Peace fam when u eat, eat right!
Book a table now
I love Bonny's Pizzeria—it's my favorite spot for pizza and wings. However, last week I ordered both and the wings were really disappointing. They weren’t fresh, extremely tough, and barely had any sauce, tasting like leftovers or from a canceled order. Hoping it was just a one-time issue, I went back the following weekend for pizza only. Despite ordering ahead, they said the cook never got the order, so I ended up waiting 45 minutes for a cheese pizza that wasn’t even fully cooked!
Although I don't usually go out of my way to visit Bonny's Pizzeria, I definitely intend to return, though I can't say when. Like many, I'm a pizza lover, but I wouldn't rank this restaurant among my top 10 favorites just yet. I often spend time around Portion Road, but I typically explore other dining options in the area.
I would give the regular slice a 4/10, but the grandma slice is a standout, earning a perfect 10/10. If you stop by, be sure to try the grandma slice!
Good food. Reasonable prices. Will ignore you as you wait at the counter like an idiot for your pick up...and hardly ever say Thank You for your purchase. Of course, par for the course these days at a lot of places. 3 heroes for the price of 2, I'll put up with it. The special ends, we avoid them like we do Little Vincent's for the same reason. For pizza I'll go to Albert's. About the same quality and price but, every once in a while, they actually do say Thank You.
The pizza is delicious, every single kind of slice you order, the meatballs are the best I ever tasted, the veal always melts in your mouth, the meatball sliders are excellent, the chicken is always tender! Everything we?ve ever gotten there is delicious! And the owner is very very nice too!
Book a table now
This is our favorite pizza place! Nothing we have had from here has been bad. Obviously the pizza is why we order primarily BUT their menu is great. We tried out their wings tonight and enjoyed them. Highly recommend. ????????
The service was exceptional. I dined there on New Year's Eve after arriving from overseas, and it completely fulfilled my craving. The chicken pesto pizza is absolutely fantastic!
Sicilian Style Baked Ziti Baked Ziti
Spaghetti With Meatballs Or Sausage
Penne With Broccoli, Garlic And Oil
Penne Broccoli Rabe And Chicken
Penne Broccoli Rabe And Sausage
Mussels Marinara Or Garlic Oil
Spaghetti With Garlic And Oil
Calamari Scungilli Marinara
Grilled Shrimp Bruschetta
Chicken Rollatine Marsala
