Request table reservation
You will maybe be redirected
"I always enjoy ordering from this restaurant. I definitely plan to order from here again."
Phone: (+1)5163543831
Address: 217 Jericho Turnpike, 11001, Floral Park, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Floral Park
Website: https://www.buttercookybakery.com/
Monday: 07:00-20:00
Tuesday: 07:00-20:00
Wednesday: 07:00-20:00
Thursday: 07:00-20:00
Friday: 07:00-20:00
Saturday: 07:00-20:00
Sunday: 07:00-20:00
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 2958
I’ve been a customer here many years. My Five stars is for all their lovely breads, cookies, and premade cakes, and all the good memories of sipping cappucino in their window waiting for my daughter to finish gymnastics class nearby. And I still order baked goods here, and cakes from the cases. However, I feel I really should add my experience to the stories of others regarding the accuracy and quality of special made to order cakes because i feel the owner and management who never seem to be there when you want them should know. FirstPhoto the flower box cake as it is usually made at Buttercooky for Mother’s Day. I love it! it’s novel, It’s luxe, it can be filled almost any way you like, an...
You're never disappointed! Customer service is always phenomenal. I came for a cheesecake two weeks ago for the holiday party of my work and everyone loved it! I also came in a bind for some cupcakes yesterday after I was told last minute that another bakery could not fulfill my order. My toddler loves chocolate cupcakes and Minnie Mouse, and she had them first in the school party. The other bakery told me 20 minutes until my pick-up time, that they had no chocolate cupcakes after I paid the order about 24 hours before and for it. I came to Buttercooky 9 when I needed the cupcakes and can you imagine my surprise when I saw these gems that fit my theme perfectly in the display case! The kids...
Strawberry Shortcake 7.5/10. While most bakeries on LI like to make a cake that is too dry, this cake is wet. Not as bad as St Rocco's strawberry crisp cake, which taste like eating a wet sponge, this is still a wet cake and ruins it. Frosting is correct, not too sweet and not too easy. The filling layers are also exactly the correct amount of cream and strawberries. It's a little sweeter than I prefer, but good. I liked everything else about this cake, except the dough is 20% damper than it should be to meet perfect moisture.
I came to this place all the way from NJ to visit a friend and we shared some pastries and desserts plus coffee, the place has a lot of personality, the staff is friendly and friendly. Their products lubricated heavenly, not too sweet, only the correct amount, they were freshly made and looked amazing. It was hard to choose from so many options. They definitely have something for each person. I'd like to come back. We should have a butterfly in NJ Book a table now
I bought the cake for my husband’s birthday because he loves Red Velvet; the inside was lovely and moist—delicious; however, the red fondant on the outside was not tasty at all. It ruins the cake and tastes ,like a chemical. We had to cut around the cake so take off the fondant. It was not a pleasant experience. I'm not sure that I would try this bakery again because I would not recommend the Red Velvet cake. It was a beautiful presentation.
The Strawberry Shortcake is incredibly delicious and fresh. The Red Velvet Cupcake, Vanilla Classic Cupcake, and Choco Classic Cupcake were all moist and tasty. I would definitely order them again. Everything arrived neatly packaged. Thank you for helping me celebrate a birthday!
This was my first time in Buttercooky Bakery, it was a wonderful experience. The staff was professional, although the line was long, it was kept fast moving it. The leaks were delicious I ate everything I bought. The butter cookies were remarkable! I will definitely be back!
Absolutely divine looking desserts. Out of this world. I have no idea how the strawberry drizzled cheesecake made it to me in perfect condition in a DoorDash, but let me tell you. It was pure perfection. Book a table now
I really adore this bakery. They offer delicious rainbow cake cookies and cakes. My personal favorite is the tres leches cake with fruits. It's fantastic!
I always enjoy ordering from this restaurant. I definitely plan to order from here again.
