My boyfriend and I frequent the Roslyn location which we love. It's been closed since the pandemic started so we thought we'd try another La Bottega expecting the same standard of food. The Carle Place location was a watered down with subpar food and service compared to Roslyn. The mozzarella sticks at Roslyn are made from scratch with fresh cheese and you can taste it; the ones in Carle Place are store bought/cheap frozen and we were given over 15 for two people. We tried one and couldn't eat them. Instead of the baked ravioli that we love in Roslyn, we were served cold ravioli, with cold mozzarella chunks thrown on top and a very muddled red sauce with everything but the kitchen sink in it...
If I could rate La Bottega in Carle Place a 10 I would. They hosted a party of 14 people celebrating 5 birthdays this past Sunday. Joe, the owner, arranged for a fantastic team to handle the party. Filipe (the chef), Anthony and Lisbeth were amazing. I don't know how Lisbeth managed not to make one single mistake, or Felipe to prepare all dishes perfectly but they did. Anthony worked quietly behind the scene to coordinate everything. And Joe, the owner, called to be sure all was going smoothly. Ordering off the full menu, everyone raved about their meal and the portions were so large that everyone had enough to take home. The cakes, carrot and chocolate mousse, were prepared that same mornin...
The linguini Alfred was bland. The service was great, but for pasta, I was really disappointed. It seemed it was a large portion, but the quality wasn't there when I visited Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 2 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3
The service was excellent. Although I wasn't a fan of my own order, I tasted my colleagues' salads and they were delicious. The woman sitting next to us kindly shared her appetizers as well. The Sangria was refreshing, though light. I would definitely return.
Book a table now
Absolutely fabulous all around. Food was delicious and I loved their Sangria. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Stuffed Eggplant
I absolutely love this place! I had a delicious piece of homemade Sicilian pizza that was incredibly fresh, along with a perfect cappuccino. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy and delightful!
Parking is quite limited, but the food is excellent, the staff is wonderful, the atmosphere is fantastic, and the prices are very reasonable.
Service was great, vodka sauce FABULOUS. ,Sangria delicious. All top quality food . Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Book a table now
Perfect place to grab a bite! Service was unbelievable!! 12/10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Eggplant Parm was a little crispy and light on the cheese ? Delicious.
