The best pizza in Roc City! I have been enjoying this delicious pizza since the 1980s. When I attended Blessed Sacrament Junior High School, we would have Captain Tony's pizza for lunch every once in a while. Those were good times. I was fortunate enough to live near this place for a few years and have taken advantage of their Wild Wednesday Special frequently in recent decades. Even though I moved away from the area a few years ago, I always make sure to come back to Captain Tony's to satisfy my craving. My wife and children have also become fans. This place has the best pizza sauce and consistently delivers a high-quality product. In my opinion, other pizzas in the city taste like plain to...
I ordered from DoorDash and this place is AMAZING!!!! I always get the calzone and the quality of the food for the price is EXCELLENT. It is one of the best places in Rochester to order a calzone. I love the taste of the Ricotta cheese, Mozzarella, and the sauce is fantastic. There is not as much dough and less filling here compared to other places. It's packed with toppings, so I believe you get your money's worth. I would recommend this place for a large calzone over any other place around.
Mid pizza.. plenty of other spots in Rochester who serve pizza with their heart and soul into it. Parking: 9-10 spots in the back behind the building. 2 entrances, one on Winton and one on Humboldt.
This pizza was absolutely amazing! I cannot give it enough stars. Every time I crave a deep dish it’s the only place I go! Five stars all the way! Thank you, Kevin and Pauley!!!
Book a table now
This is the best pizza I've ever had. The staff is really friendly and helpful. Next time, I will definitely try the wings, which are baked to perfection. WO
Our usual pizza spot recently closed down, so we decided to give this place a try. The pizza was fantastic! We’ve found our new favorite pizza place!
This restaurant has truly stood the test of time. My family has been enjoying Captain Tony's for over 40 years, and their pizza is fantastic!
Greatest pizza shop in North Winton village area. Food, atmosphere and service always with a smile. Couldn't be happier Everytime we order.
Book a table now
The got thanked me for ordering, food was out quick and tasted great had nice crispy crust
Mean pizza and Sin Stix. Everything was very good. Sin Stick had so much Icing
4 Pieces Garlic Bread With Mozzarella Cheese And Slice Of Tomato
4 Pieces Garlic Bread With Delicious Mozzarella Cheese
New York Super Slice Extra Cheese Pepperoni Pizza
Captain’s Cattleman Low Carb Deep Dish Pizza
New York Super Slice Double Cheese Pizza
Spaghetti And Meatball Deep Dish Pizza
Captain’s Cattleman Low Carb Pizza
Party Sheet Pizza Biggest In Town!
Philly Cheesesteak Deep Dish Pizza
Baked And Breaded Chicken Parmesan
