Dined there last night. The hostess and server were both great. Clean and comfortable dining area. We had the Carfagna Bruschetta and it well exceeded our expectations. The dip that came with the bread was really good. The spicy creamy chicken rigatelli was great. We also had the meat combination The chicken parmigiana, meat ravioli, and meatballs were good. The lasagna seemed almost nonexistent under all the sauce but it wasn't bad. The brussels sprouts were very good. Got tiramisu and cannoli from the market. The tiramisu was, as always, extremely delicious.
Years ago when I lived in Columbus Carfagna's was an excellent Italian deli/meat market, but I moved away before it transformed into the food emporium it became. This was my first time at the restaurant. I went with extended family for my aunt's birthday and really liked it. Food was solidly good Italian standards and service was excellent. Everyone was happy. Now that I have moved back to Worthington, I expect to come here regularly as my wife is highly pasta dependent. I also want to explore the new deli and the wine shop.
The experience was average. I ordered the chicken parmesan. The chicken piece was thick but dry, with very little cheese on it – just a small sprinkle of shredded cheese on top. The pasta was overcooked. It was quite expensive for the quality of food my wife and I received.
Loved it! We came here after a golf lesson and had a great time. The food was awesome and the service was so fast. And the wine selection was amazing. After lunch we did a wine tasting and met new friends. We will definitely be back! I had the grouper- it was delicious.
Book a table now
Love this place! The food was delicious from the appetizers to the main course and the dessert. Had a great bottle of wine too. Our server was friendly and fun. Love how spacious this place is. Didn’t get to shop in the market but looking forward to going back.
The food and service at this restaurant are top-notch. Upon entering, we were impressed by the bakery and grocery store within. The wide variety of items available in both sections truly amazed me.
They always have the prime rib I want every Christmas. They have plenty of things to choose from. The guy was helpful.
Delicious food and superb service! After you're done eating, you can go shopping! Wine, Liquor amazing meats cheeses.
Book a table now
1st time going and really good food and service and atmosphere
This is the perfect spot to find genuine Italian groceries.
Spaghetti, Fettuccine, Or Rigatelli
Spicy Creamy Chicken Rigatelli
Italian Roast Beef Sandwich
Mini Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken Or Veal Parmigiana
