We're from PA originally, and finding GOOD pizza (non-bitter sauce, firm stone-baked dough) is difficult in SC. We had slices only but were impressed. Well, Cartoni's is a winner for us! An employee said dough is made fresh daily. They need wait staff so you order at the counter entrance or by phone. Turns out the owner is from the Reading, PA area used to own Ozzy's Family Fun Center on Route 61 outside of Leesport (my hubby's hometown). Parking: The dirt parking lot is located directly off Route 52 (north side). Totally accessible but a wheelchair or walker may have a bumpy ride.
The food here is phenomenal! The portion sizes are generous, and the customer service has consistently been outstanding. I've been visiting for the past five years, and it's become a staple for my family and me on a weekly basis. I highly recommend trying it if you're in the area—you won't forget it, and you certainly won't regret it. Thank you, Cartonis, for your incredible food and excellent service! I haven't had a single disappointing experience in the five years I've been coming here. Keep up the great work!
I love this place when I’m having trouble finding something that I like to eat or feed my family I don’t have to take long coming up with a solution to be honest they have been the best place for food in town and I don’t see that changing anytime soon very nice customer service and owner is particularly nice to chat with. Would recommend going there at least once you won’t regret it you will become regulars like my family has. Love love love them!!
If you love the pizza from Stefano’s, then Cartoni’s won’t let you down. Some true authentic Italian food. Antipasto salad is a little different than Stefano’s, it has bell pepper and iceberg lettuce, but still delicious. The baked bread with marinara was mouth watering. Philly cheese didn’t disappoint. More convenient to Lake City. Wheelchair accessibility: Sidewalk does have grading to the parking lot.
Book a table now
Was in the area so I stopped. Nice place, I ordered a Stromboli special. It was awesome. I haven't had Italian this good in a long time. The crust was perfectly done, the Stromboli was almost 2' long. Had a great taste and the sauce did not disappoint. The pricing was very fair. If ur close check this place out for sure.
I always have an amazing experience at this restaurant! The food is delicious, and the prices are great every time I visit. The staff is friendly, and the owner is fantastic. I highly recommend this place!
Literally the best Italian food you're going to find around here! Go here often and it seems the next dish I try is always my new favorite.?
Everything was great, but the dough was quite tough. It seems like it might have been overworked.
Book a table now
Being from Philly this is the best cheesesteak we have had since moving here
Great food, friendly staff. Best pizza joint around the Lake city area.
