Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria is a fantastic spot! As someone with family from Brooklyn, New York, I can confidently say the pizza is excellent—the sauce is flavorful, the cheese is fantastic, and the dough is just right. The mozzarella caprese was also top-notch. The staff was friendly, and the food came out quickly. It's an awesome place, nearly capturing that New York style pie experience. However, I did order a cannoli after writing this review, and unfortunately, it was quite hard, which is not how it should be. On the positive side, the ricotta cheese inside was pretty delicious. Overall, check out the menu – there's a lot to love!
I was craving brick oven pizza and discovered this spot in northern Columbus. We were greeted right away and noticed it was surprisingly empty around 6 pm. We were seated immediately and placed our order within minutes. During our meal, at least 25 takeout orders were picked up, and the place quickly filled up. The pizzas were excellent, service was fast, and you can even see the brick oven in the back! Their sauce is nothing short of magical—so delicious you could almost drink it. Highly recommend the Margherita with added bacon and pepperoni. You’re going to love it!
We decided to visit Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria because my friend was craving some nostalgic New York-style pizza. We ordered the Supreme Pizza, and the bill for a square pizza and one drink came to $26.75, with the pizza alone costing $21. While it was decent for the Columbus area, it didn't come close to authentic New York pizza. We definitely overpaid. The pizza was large, but it lacked seasoning and the sauce was bland. I won’t be returning; I’d much rather go to Johnny's Pizza down the street.
We walked in because my friend was feeling nostalgic and wanted to get some good NY Style Pizza. We got the Supreme Pizza and the total for a Square Pizza with one drink came out to $26.75. The pizza was $21. Honestly...it was decent for the Columbus Area but not New York at all. Overpaid for sure. The pizza was pretty big but it lacked spices and the sauce was plain. Won'tbe coming here again. Would rather go to Johnny's Pizza down the street.
Book a table now
Absolutely the best pizza in Columbus! I proudly admit that we ordered from here two days in a row. My husband, who was stationed in Italy, claims it tastes just as good as what he had there. The crust had the perfect amount of char, and the flavors were exceptional! You have to try this place—you won't be disappointed!
Hands down the best pizza in Columbus I have no shame in admitting that we got pizza from here two days in a row. My husband was stationed in Italy and said this is just as good as what he had there. The crust had a delicious bit of char, just the rightamount. The flavors were delicious! Just go here.
I haven’t had pizza this tasty in a long time. Clearly, Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria is one of Columbus’s best-kept secrets. The pizza is authentic, bursting with amazing flavors, and you can really feel the dedication they bring to their craft!
Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria is our top choice for pizza in Columbus. Their menu features fantastic pies, complemented by a rotating selection of regional beers. The staff are friendly and welcoming, making it a true gem in the city.
Book a table now
I know Leo, the owner, and he's a wonderful person. I decided to give Cerrones a try, and it definitely lives up to the expectations. It's a solid five stars all around!
Fantastic pizza! Much better than any chain restaurant! You should definitely give this place a try.
Pesto Chicken Artichoke Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Traditional Meatlovers Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Sensational Mushroom Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Cerrone Margherita Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
The Alla Vodka Pie Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Build Your Own New York Style Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Quattro Formaggi Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Smoking Cerrone Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Spicy Hawaiian Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza
