Colosseum New York Pizza

I can't give this place any higher than 4 out of 5 star review. I ordered medium combo pizza, garlic knots and Caesar salad. To my surprise, they charged over 3 for a small portion of anchovies and 7 for Caesar salad. For 7.00 I would expect would be more but instead it looked like 4 Romaine lettuce blades chopped, croutons and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese with a small container of Caesar salad dressing. Don't get me wrong, their pizza was DELISH and that I completely support the mom pop businesses but I don't support business that charge every grain of salt used in a dish. If I do go back to this pizza joint, it will be ONLY for pizza. I give 5 stars to businesses that provide exceptional...

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Take it from a native New Yorker, this is the most authentic NY-style pizza I have found outside of the tri-state area. Used to like ASONY until I discovered this place. Chewy yet crispy thin crust, not hard or cracker-y or too bread-y. The flavor, texture, and consistency of the sauce and cheese are just right too. My favorite is the owner's favorite, cheese and fresh tomatoes. The margherita is good, too, though a bit messy. My only complaint is that I used to come here for late night munchies but ever since they started sometimes closing before their posted closing hours, I just pivoted to other late night options after getting burned a couple times. The nearby establishments can get real...

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

If you're looking for a reliable and efficient food delivery service, look no further than Colosseum New York Pizza! I've been a loyal customer for months now, and I'm always impressed by their professionalism. They take care to ensure that my orders arrive promptly and in perfect condition. The menu selection is extensive, catering to various dietary preferences, and the quality of the food is exceptional. Colosseum New York Pizza has definitely become my go-to choice for convenient and tasty meals at home. Give them a try—you won't be disappointed!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Tldr: try New York Style Pizza and the meatball sandwich. Try the Sicilian pizza with dough well done.New York Pizza some are sold by the slice. It's good.Meatball sandwich best meatball sub you can get. I would pick this place over Ike's for this item.Stromboli lots of filling. Very cheesy.Chicken Wings goodSicilien Pizza really good. I recommend adding ricotta and requesting the dough well done (mine was a bit soft on top but that could be from the moisture of the ingredients).

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

The pizzas taste okay, and it’s a great find in the middle of nowhere. However, with a bit of improvement in the atmosphere, it could become a real treasure. Worth stopping by for a delicious slice! Hoping for better improvements in the future.Food: 3/5

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply