Costello's Tavern

Costello's Tavern - Table reservation

723 Centre St, Jamaica Plain, United States Of America, 02130 Reservation
3.7 /5
1725 Reviews

"Burgers are delicious. Service is great. Pizza just okay."

Details

Phone: +16175229263,+16175225885

Address: 723 Centre St, Jamaica Plain, United States Of America, 02130

Reservation, Booking

City: Jamaica Plain

Website: https://www.costellostavern.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 16:00-02:00

Tuesday: 16:00-02:00

Wednesday: 16:00-02:00

Thursday: 11:00-14:00

Friday: 11:00-14:00

Saturday: 11:00-14:00

Sunday: 11:00-14:00

Statistics

Dishes: 4

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1725


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Cody

1/5

Well, I have lived in JP many years and I never went to Costello's because they didn't have good veggie friendly meals. So I thought I would try it with Boston Burger.Mistake. I got a veggie burger with barbecue sauce and onion rings lettuce and tomato. The onion rings were completely soggy, the tomatos were the ends that you usually dispose of, and the entire burger was mush. If I'm paying $3 to have onion rings on my burger I want them to be crispy, not a watered-down mess.Also the restaurant took so long making this little sandwich that GrubHub assigned three different drivers to pick this up because they all waited so long. Each driver waited for this burger to be made and then they gave...

Sim

4/5

This review is for delivery from the new kitchen, which is now a Boston Burger Co outpost. As with other BBC sites, the menu with many turkeys and veggie burger options is exciting with all kinds of combos and toppings, something you do not often find at a 'burger joint'. I was not disappointed with the results either - our meal was tasteful, fill and overall pleasant as we have experienced in the past with other BBC sites. Perhaps the experience is better in-person, as we have experienced a few disadvantages that were probably specific to the delivery. The burger containers were not labeled so that we had to take them apart to determine what was that they only came with 1 side instead of th...

Tiana

5/5

The best burgers in JP! The atmosphere is fantastic! You won't find a better-priced drink with top-shelf options anywhere else! They have been remodeled and are now OPEN! They offer a late-night bar from Thursday to Saturday, so make sure to drop by! You won't be disappointed! Just one request... PLEASE BRING BACK CHILLED GLASSES FOR THE BEER!! It's summertime, and there's nothing better than a frosty glass for my Sam Summer, which pairs perfectly with the Costello Burger (don’t forget to add sautéed onions)!

Crystel

4/5

We live in JP and have not been there since 2018 due to poor service and unstoppable food quality....until last night. We had seen the announcement that Boston Burgers had taken over the kitchen, so we decided to try again. Fully worth it! Service was excellent, drinks were fast and the burgers were very good. We saw the Bruins win with a great deal. Just the reason we don't give 5 stars the bar is missing a few ingredients to make the first drink I requested. We're definitely going back. Book a table now

Daron

5/5

She saved our night after our shy experience in the coolidge corner clubhouse lmao. This is only 9 minutes from CCC, so I highly recommend the selection of costellos instead if you do the headline to CCC tonight a favor and choose Costellos instead, your welcome in advance.

Mazie

5/5

Boston Burger arrived and food is fantastic. Try the garlic parm wing with the coldest beer. Burgers are huge and come in many varieties. Service is great and they have some of the best bartenders around! Well done!

Davin

5/5

Great place to watch a game and always a generous pour of Bourbon. Book a table now


Dishes

Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers

Fried Pickles
Fried Pickles

Hot Dog
Hot Dog

Wings
Wings