Crabby Amy's

Crabby Amy's - Table reservation

2880 Ocean Avenue, Seaford, NY 11783, United States
857 Reviews 3.7

"Great location, atmosphere, and beer. Place was busy for a Wednesday late lunch. Was disappointed by the food though. Fish was paper thin and clams looked like what you get in the frozen section of the grocery store."

Details

Phone: +15167832554

Address: 2880 Ocean Avenue, Seaford, NY 11783, United States

City: Seaford

Website: https://www.crabby-amys.com

Opening hours

Monday: 08:00-21:00

Tuesday: 08:00-21:00

Wednesday: 08:00-21:00

Thursday: 08:00-21:00

Friday: 08:00-21:00

Saturday: 08:00-22:00

Sunday: 08:00-22:00

Statistics

Dishes: 8

Amenities: 9

Categories: 5

Reviews: 857


Address

Show Map

Reviews

2 /5 Rating

WHAT [A] VIEW! ...? Dockside seating sounds like it would be nice, except it means that boat hulls are staring you in the face the whole time. Not much water to look at. GET YA BEER H--oh wait The roast beef sandwich also sounded nice for the land-lover of the group, but they were SOLD OUT at 3pm on a Sunday. Also SOLD OUT of the beer he wanted. At least you can 't screw up lobster... Turns out you can....We went specifically for the lobster roll (paired with the outdoor dining), but the MP (i.e. $30) item was very disappointing on all fronts. The server was very nice, though, so she 's earned the extra star I gave. Maybe she can turn it into a NFT and wear it on her attire as one of her 37...

4 /5 Rating

I really enjoyed this place is my first time here I've heard about it a lot of times. It was a cool place to come have a couple drinks by the water, we had some clams and some muscles it was cute and quiet. The staff was very friendly constantly checking on us to see if we want anything else. pretty sure it gets busy at in the evening was starting to get crowded when we left. This parking in the marina itself against the fence so we didn't have to worry about that. Pretty nice crowd mixed families and couples and friends just having a good old time. Definitely we're checking it out.

5 /5 Rating

Crabby Amy's is a fabulous little place right on the water. It gives you a classic Long Island vibe. The food is served very fast and the waiters and waitresses are so kind. Their specialty is the seafood however I don't like seafood so I went with the chicken tenders.(very adventurous of me, I know) They were amazing and very filling. We also got fries for the table which were tasty. There are many tables right on the water however many of those don't have shaded areas so don't forget to wear sunscreen and a hat! Enjoy!

1 /5 Rating

We were just there on Saturday night...we got our drinks and appetizers but waited an hour and a half before our waiter told us they ran out of the bread rolls for the lobster roll...totally unacceptable! When we approached the manager she said that they had just opened yesterday, but why let us wait that long?! Never again!

3 /5 Rating

Great location, atmosphere, and beer. Place was busy for a Wednesday late lunch. Was disappointed by the food though. Fish was paper thin and clams looked like what you get in the frozen section of the grocery store.


Dishes

Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders

Lobster Roll
Lobster Roll

B.l.t.
B.l.t.

Blt
Blt

Fish And Chips
Fish And Chips

Popcorn Shrimp
Popcorn Shrimp

Fried Shrimp
Fried Shrimp

Crab Cake
Crab Cake