Came here during a road trip from Kansas City to Chicago and was told by my travel partner about, “horseshoe sandwiches.” This is the first I’ve ever heard of or tasted a horseshoe sandwich and it was DELICIOUS. I chose Nashville hot chicken for my meat with spicy cheese sauce and it was flavorful and tasty! I also had a tasty local beer recommended by our super friendly waitress. I would rarely find myself in Springfield being from Kansas City, but I’d love to come back some day and share this meal with someone who hasn’t had the experience. Thanks for the great food and hospitality!
We went yesterday for a late lunch. It was pretty busy so we waited for about 15 min, not a big deal. Our server was super nice and really helpful. Fried green tomatoes, chili, and the supreme and the other horse shoe we ordered were amazing! Definitely will be back next time we are in town. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Horse Shoe
Excellent food and fast service!! Husband had the Supreme horseshoe which is crumbled burger, bacon, green onions, tomatoes, and side of hot sauce. I had the Irish Cheesesteak horseshoe which is sirloin with mushrooms, onions, and peppers. I chose to not have the onions and peppers as they don't agree with me. They were excellent!!! $12.99 each.
it came highly recommended so we tried it. Famous for their Horseshoe but honestly it didn’t really appeal to me. The menu has a great variety to choose from. Our waitress was super friendly. All the food was good. Nachos. Black and Bleu salad. Grilled chicken Smoked gouda chipotle apple butter sandwich.
Book a table now
We had 3 variations of their ponyshoe ham, hamburger and supreme. (Supreme is crumbled burger, bacon, green onions, tomatoes, and side of hot sauce. All served hot and fresh. White cheese sauce was absolutely the best. Large portions and reasonably priced. Great quality food and pleasant wait staff.
First time there and I tried the Horse-shoe. Was delicious! The white cheese sauce they use is way better than cheddar that normally is on a horse shoe. The staff are polite and provided fast service. Definitely can see why people love to come here.
Omg. What a wonderful find. Horse shoes and pony shoes at their finest. Originated in Springfield IL. Over 10 different meat choices and two choices of yummy cheese sauces. Went back several times. Quick service and great food. Pony shoes pictured.
This was one of my favorite meals of all time. There will be a time when I drive from the Chicago area just for this. All four of us got different pony shoes. Fantastic!
Book a table now
Has been on TV several times for a reason. Great food and good Irish pub/restaurant feel. Authentic food and great horseshoes!
Nice place, staff was good. Is it the best horseshoe in town? Only you can answer that...
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Bacon Smoked Gouda Raspberry Chipotle Apple Butter Burger
Bacon Smoked Gouda Raspberry Chipotle Apple Butter
Cheese Toasty/Irish Bacon And Tomato
Child's Parmesan Buttered Noodles
Toasted Buffalo Chicken Ravioli
Strawberry Salad With Chicken
Large Italian Tossed Salad
