First of all, the pizza and salad were outstanding. I can't imagine ordering from anywhere else in Stoughton now. The only issue I encountered was with a young girl who was working there. When she brought our food, my wife asked about an ingredient in a particular salad, and instead of providing an answer, the girl replied, "I don't know, but I can bring a menu." She completely skipped over the option of finding out for us. When we were leaving, I passed by the register to thank them for the great meal, but the same girl was lounging on a table behind the counter, staring at her phone and never even looked up. I understand that staffing can be a challenge, but the other employees should addr...
Exceptional pizza featuring unique creations that are expertly prepared and baked to perfection. I tried the deep dish pizza, which was stuffed with spaghetti and had a crust filled with cheese and meatballs. The tangy, spicy sauce was so delicious that it left me wanting more. Great job, Cale! I also enjoyed a thin crust pizza topped with fresh basil. I'm definitely coming back!
The pizza was prepared with fresh ingredients and looked decent, but the flavor and taste were just average—not anything special. In my opinion, it's hard to find great pizza around here. The restaurant itself was clean and tidy, but it lacked ambiance or atmosphere. The staff were friendly, though.
The odd location shouldn’t deter you. The pizza is fantastic. I had the stuffed pizza (margarita) and it didn’t disappoint. The device was great. When I mentioned that this was my first time there, the host gave me some cheesy bread to eat before our meal. I will definitely be coming back!
Book a table now
Amazing Service inside a fast paced environment. Food was amazing, house made salad dressing is excellent. Staff treated everybody with respect despite being busy. Pizza was delicious. Will definitely recommend.
Best best best pizza in Stoughton let alone in Wisconsin! We are so lucky to have Yeti’s! Their stuffed crust is amazing but hand tossed is impeccable too! Try the Greek salad, it’s so fresh and delicious!
No delivery, no parking. Someone taking orders and not ringing them up was the first thing they said. Place chaotic but pizza pretty good.
Most scrumptious stuffed pizza ever consumed by us … so good we over ate. Very fresh ingredients. Tasty crust. Highly recommended.
Book a table now
Pizza was great! Atmosphere is fine. The service was so bad! They forgot our salad and then messed up our toppings. ??.
I go here every couple of days. The pizza is good, the place is clean, and it's easy to get to.
