While passing through Madison on our way home, we decided to stop for a quick meal, and it turned out to be the best decision of our trip! The staff were friendly and very patient with my grandkids. We ordered mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, two individual pizzas, wings, and a large specialty pizza. Everything was absolutely delicious—definitely one of the best pizza places I've ever tried. The only downside is that I won't be able to become a regular customer in the future. Thank you all for the wonderful and tasty food! If we pass through again, this will be our top choice.
I absolutely love this place! It's exactly what you need. The pizza is fantastic, but my spouse and I also stopped by for some hot subs while taking a walk on New Year’s Day, and they were delicious as well! The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming. I hope this doesn't sound like a phony review, but I genuinely appreciate Glass Nickel and am thrilled to have it in our community!
The best toasted ravioli I've tried outside of St. Louis, MO. Their cracker crust pizza is fantastic, the service is excellent, and they have a nice selection of taps.
We made a mistake with our online order and they caught it, delivered it before the ETA and everything was perfect! A classic Madison pizza place for a reason.
Book a table now
Seriously the best pizza around! The flavor is always spot on. I even ordered some to take back for my husband after my concert because he also enjoys it.
The best gluten-free crust I've ever had in town! I also really love the intimate, hole-in-the-wall atmosphere at the bar in the east side location.
The food and service are consistently great. The restaurant can feel a bit crowded during dinner time.
Ordered for the first time. Excellent pizza, better than the chain store pizzas.
Book a table now
Consistently excellent pizza and service. It's one of our top choices in town!
Great food and service plus a free 10 Pizza for my Birthday month.
10" Cheeseasaurus Pizza With Gluten-Free Crust
10" Sacre Bleu Pizza With Gluten-Free Crust
10" Bacon Cheeseburger Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Portabella Lugosi Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Border To Border Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Boaris Karloff Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Cardiac Arrest Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Mediterranean Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Vegan Delight Gluten-Free Pizza
10" Breakfast Pie Gluten-Free Pizza
