Disclaimer: I have never dined at this location, only delivery. That being said, I have ordered from here 3x and every time something was wrong with the order. I ordered the shrimp Romulus in the past, they sent penne with capers sauce and no protein at all. Uber Eats Gave me a refund, but seriously? Before that I ordered 2 pizzas and they only sent one ?! , again Uber Eats reimbursed me. The today they send me 2 lobster bisque that have NO FUKN LOBSTER AT ALL!! Some chopped up ravioli in some kind of vodka sauce that wasn't bisque. I heard such good stories about this place, they must all be just that, stories. Thrice burned, never again, so much better pizza establishments on the island.
This restaurant/pizzeria has some of the best pizza in New York City. I truly enjoy their brick oven old world pizza. It’s absolutely delicious and it’s worth driving to have it.The restaurant has indoor seating area as well as an enclosed outdoor seating area. The staff are always friendly and welcoming. The restaurant is also very clean and kept well. There are plenty of street parking around the restaurant.If you’ve found this review helpful, please consider clicking the helpful button and follow me for more adventures!
My experience at Goodfellas was mediocre the restaurant has a beautiful interior and our server was alright. The pricing was decent for NY. My complaint is the pizza they have a bunch or award winning pizzas dating back to the 2000s which is nice but when I got the penne vodka pizza is was mediocre. I’m not sure if they have a new owner of lost standards but the pizza was not great especially for NYC. The antipasto was very good. Overall maybe the pasta and meat dishes are better but I wouldn’t recommend the pizza.
Great menu with lots to choose from. Very clean dining area and bathrooms. The staff are friendly and customer oriented. I will definitely return.
Book a table now
Hands down THE BEST pizza on Staten Island!
Before I go into the review I want call out the yelpers who left this place negative reviews.
Pizza was not the correct size that I ordered previously and was charged the same price.
The pizza had a chemical smell and tasted like it was a week old.
Ordered take out from here last nightI ordered 4 simple items.
Book a table now
Cant speak for the regular pizza but gluten free wasnt good.
Ordered the goodfella sandwich and side of meatballs online.
Eggplant, Roasted Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella
Chicken, Roasted Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella
Fried Calamari Mixed W. Sweet Chili Sauce
Home-Made Mozzarella ‘N Carrozza (4 Pcs)
Boneless Buffalo Chicken Tenders (5)
Homemade Mozzarella, Tomatoes Basil
Kid’s Pizza W/ Shredded Mozzarella
Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari
Pizza Bianca (White Pizza)Small 4
Maryland Style Crab Cakes (2 Pcs)
