I've had my eye on this place for a while, particularly for the lobster roll. While we were at Harbor Island Park early in the day, we decided to stop by. Initially, we were informed that we couldn’t order the lunch combo because it was the weekend, which I don’t recall being mentioned on the menu. I honestly should have walked away at that point. I understand this is Westchester, but the prices felt steep for the quality of the food. Perhaps we just had an off experience, but the lobster was chewy and the bread was stale. In the fried combo, the fries tasted like they were cooked in old oil, and the seafood was heavily seasoned with black pepper, which overshadowed the overall flavor. I had...
Unfortunately, the prices are a bit on the higher side, but that’s understandable given the quality of the seafood, which can be harder to find. Additionally, the space, while charmingly small, can be quite dirty at times. Given everything that’s happened in the past year and a half, that might put some people off, but I personally don’t mind, as the freshness of the seafood is rare in this area. This place outshines many waterfront restaurants in Westchester and is a great choice for a quick lunch or catered meal. I’m grateful to them for satisfying my seafood cravings on so many occasions!
Was in the mood for seafood and wanted to try this place out. How does this qualify as a crab cake sandwich? I ordered via GrubHub, where it said served on a kaiser roll with lettuce , got home and opened this up, a sole crab cake with no roll or lettuce in site...really? $20 for this? I also got the calamari which are so thin you 're basically eating just batter. I 'm sorry but not worth the money. The only thing I liked was the tartar sauce.
Pleasantly surprised As someone that is not a big seafood lover, I do love to eat fried shrimp and my usual go-to place is Johhny's Reef at City Island. That being the case sometimes it a bit out of the way from where I live and this place is a more than good enough. The shrimp was great and according to my wife the shrimp po-boy was delicious
Book a table now
This place is a gem!!! I have quite few food allergies and it's always a scare to eat out and especially fish ... the staff was super friendly and understood my allergies, prepared my food just how I needed it to be. All was fresh and super tasty!!! This is my new go to for sure... 100% recommended
I ordered fried seafood and there was no flavor no seasoning was so disappointed I also ordered the seafood paella and that was even worst with overloaded spices but no seasoning. I spent all that money over bad food the only good thing about the place is the staff very nice
I was extremely disappointed when I arrived home, I did not have all the items I ordered. When I called the restaurant, the owner seems unconcerned. I traveled a distance to get there, but no mention on how he would correct the mistake. Bad business!!!
The staff were incredibly friendly and answered all of my questions—trust me, I had quite a few! I tried the shrimp jumbo appetizer, and to say I was pleasantly surprised by this place would be an understatement!
Book a table now
Great service. Maine lobster roll was great and I would recommend it, onion rings n chipotle Mayo were good. The New England style clam chowder was a little bland and brothy.
They have fresh fish during the pandemic. It was great service int he store as well as delivery. Very customer friendly.
