Irish Coffee Pub

Irish Coffee Pub - Table reservation

131 Carleton Avenue, East Islip, 11730, United States Of America
2277 Reviews 4.6

"Always exceptional?..Service is great. The vibe remains classic and the food is excellent. Pro tip I tried last night?. Ordered a mixed bowl of beef barley and potato soup? the best of both worlds!"

Details

Phone: +16312770007

Address: 131 Carleton Avenue, East Islip, 11730, United States Of America

City: East Islip

Website: http://www.irishcoffeepub.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:00-12:00

Tuesday: 11:00-12:00

Wednesday: 11:00-12:00

Thursday: 11:00-12:00

Friday: 11:00-24:00

Saturday: 01:00-02:00 12:00-24:00

Sunday: 01:00-03:00 12:00-24:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Amenities: 18

Categories: 5

Reviews: 2277


Address

Show Map

Reviews

3 /5 Rating

I was at some Irish Coffee Pub events. Every time I was totally enthusiastic about how attentive the staff was and the amazing quality of food. Since we had such wonderful experiences, we held a small (40 people party for my son in the summer of 2021. Again, nothing short of amazing. When I was entrusted to throwing a bridal shower for a family member, there was no competition. Of course we picked the Irish Coffee Pub. But this time it fell completely short and was extremely disappointing. Since we were the first party of the day, we were able to show up 1.5 hours before the party was founded. Thank you very much for doing this, because the staff did not help at all at the establishment. (co...

5 /5 Rating

We have always enjoyed going to the Irish Coffee Pub. The food, drinks and service always impeccable but the meal we had on St Patrick's day was the best ever. The prime rib was cooked exactly to order, so tasty and tender, comparable to any NYC steak house. Everything else also delicious, but the prime rib surpassed our expectations. The music was also wonderful. Thanks so much for a memorable St Patrick's day! And a big thank you to Stephen and staff. The professionalism is only surpassed by everyone's friendliness and going the extra few steps to make sure all is well.

4 /5 Rating

Had my son's first birthday here this last weekend and overall was happy with the experience. The service could have been slightly better and more organized as some plates weren't served all around. However, Katie and Meagan were lovely to deal with in planning the party and I was even given the whole upstairs and run of the floor for my party and activities at no extra charge because I was the only party at the time. The food was good and the price very fair. Will use them again in the future.

5 /5 Rating

Went on 3/16 for St Patrick?s day as that was the day my granddaughters could take off from school. Food was amazing every staff member was so professional and attentive. You get what you pay for. Not my first time there and will not be my last. Our waitress was amazing (sorry I don?t remember your name) to the owner your workers make you look more than good.

5 /5 Rating

Always exceptional?..Service is great. The vibe remains classic and the food is excellent. Pro tip I tried last night?. Ordered a mixed bowl of beef barley and potato soup? the best of both worlds!


Dishes

Bacon-Wrapped Horseradish Crusted Sea Scallops
Bacon-Wrapped Horseradish Crusted Sea Scallops

Pepper Seared Ahi Tuna Over Asian Slaw
Pepper Seared Ahi Tuna Over Asian Slaw

Center-Cut Bacon-Wrapped Filet Mignon*
Center-Cut Bacon-Wrapped Filet Mignon*

Little Neck Clams On Half Shell (Raw)
Little Neck Clams On Half Shell (Raw)

Tequila Lime Marinated Chicken Wrap
Tequila Lime Marinated Chicken Wrap

Black Angus New York Sirloin Steak*
Black Angus New York Sirloin Steak*

Ice Cold Little Neck Clams (Raw)
Ice Cold Little Neck Clams (Raw)

French Onion Soup Au Gratinee
French Onion Soup Au Gratinee

Pacific Coast Shrimp Cocktail
Pacific Coast Shrimp Cocktail

Black Angus New York Sirloin*
Black Angus New York Sirloin*