Jackie Reilly's

Jackie Reilly's - Table reservation

3964 Hempstead Turnpike, Bethpage, United States Of America, 11756 Reservation
4 /5
1785 Reviews

"Good food at reasonable prices. Wings, coned beef, onion soup awesome. Nice specials too."

Details

Phone: +15167317544

Address: 3964 Hempstead Turnpike, Bethpage, United States Of America, 11756

Reservation, Booking

City: Bethpage

Website: http://jackiereillys.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:30-04:00

Tuesday: 11:30-04:00

Wednesday: 11:30-04:00

Thursday: 11:30-04:00

Friday: 11:30-04:00

Saturday: 11:30-04:00

Sunday: 11:30-04:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 1785


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Dan

3/5

Service was fantastic. They were friendly, attentive, and professional. Atmosphere, well a little long in the tooth now. Let's face it though, for me it's a bar that serves food. The food.....reasonable prices and the food is ok. The wings were good (middle of the pack) compared to others that I've had. I had the steak sandwich and the meat was done to order, and was decent quality. The big issue was the frozen French fries. They were underdone and not much taste. But there was a lot of them! Nothing to deter me from going back, I would just try different things on the menu on our next visit.

Ryan

5/5

Wow! What an amazing experience! Celebrating St. Patrick's Day at this restaurant with a group of four was an absolute joy. The atmosphere was vibrant, enhanced by traditional Irish live music. We enjoyed a variety of delicious dishes and drinks, with portions that truly amazed us. And the Shepherd's Pie—simply perfection, raising the bar for quality. I can't recommend this place enough to anyone seeking a memorable dining experience. You can count on me to return without a second thought!

Dem

1/5

owner doesn’t know what he’s doing or talking about. denies 7 people that are 21+ because he “said so” wouldn’t give us a reason why, just said “i don’t care it’s my bar i don’t need to give you a reason.” seems like he just wants his clientele to be strictly firefighters, doesn’t care about getting money from anyone else. don’t waste your time. Service: 1

Bill

3/5

Very accommodating to our large group. Great set up and very good service. The food wasn't really good but that was so important, it was a gathering after a funeral. But I'm not sure if go back to eat there based on this experience. Book a table now

Don

4/5

I didn't eat, so there was no rating on that.We invaded with a large crowd, but they accommodated us nonetheless. Generous pours, lots of room for our crowd. Decent parking too.

Robert

4/5

It's just a place we used for a pre-event high school reunion. 50 years is a major milestone. Parking: Shared parking lot Wheelchair accessibility: No steps in doorway

Bandit

2/5

Took over an hour and a half for chicken Marsala. I could’ve went to Stop Shop across the road and made it in less time Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 4

Kyler

5/5

I don't even need to elaborate on how fantastic this place was. The food was outstanding, and the atmosphere was incredible. I can't wait to return! Book a table now

Patrick

5/5

Popped in today with My Great Friend Noel!! Sean Reilly and Jen the Bartender has been helping us out for over 25 yrs. The best!!!!

Chuck

5/5

Good food at reasonable prices. Wings, coned beef, onion soup awesome. Nice specials too.


Dishes

French Dip Sandwich
French Dip Sandwich

Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers

Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Chicken

Soup Of The Day
Soup Of The Day

Fish And Chips
Fish And Chips

Steak Sandwich
Steak Sandwich

Buffalo Wings
Buffalo Wings

Chicken Salad
Chicken Salad

Filet Mignon
Filet Mignon

Shepherd's Pie
Shepherd's Pie