Jersey Mike's Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs

548 New York Ave, 07071, Lyndhurst, US, United States Reservation
3.7 /5
851 Reviews

"The #8 club sub was excellent; it would have been even better with some bacon!"

Details

Phone: (+1)2017777057

Address: 548 New York Ave, 07071, Lyndhurst, US, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Lyndhurst

Opening hours

Monday: 10:00-20:30

Tuesday: 10:00-20:30

Wednesday: 10:00-20:30

Thursday: 10:00-20:30

Friday: 10:00-20:30

Saturday: 10:00-20:30

Sunday: 10:00-20:30

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 851


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Hans

5/5

I only have the highest praises for this eatery, nay, this restaurant, nay, this gastronomic experience! The bread were as soft as the clouds of heaven as I first bit in, with it expanding my understanding of the depth and complexity of simple sandwich bread, with it being comparable to even Ezekiel's biblical loaf. I would like to continue with the equal balance of the crispness, and tenderness of the vegetables, and the sour bite of the pickles, perfectly balancing each other out to create a thought provokingly refreshing experience with each bite. The cheese, as well, was a perfectly complexly creamy and savory delight that added much needed contrast, as well as substance to the sandwich....

Austyn

3/5

I'm surprised to read all bad reviews about this location. Differnt shift and different people, I guess, it's possible to have bad reviews if the right combination of customers and employees interact. However, you never know with folk nowadays whether they're telling the truth or just being a little dramatic...to each is own..As for me, I never had a bad experience both on online ordering and in person. My orders are always done to order and I never felt like anyone was being rude. I'm there for a sub not to make friends with the employees so my expectations are to be asked what sandwich I want, whether it mike way or not and what's my total at checkout. I never take it personal if I don't g...

Taya

3/5

I understand that it was 1 o'clock and likely a busy time, but I waited 10 minutes in line before anyone acknowledged my presence. After I placed my order, they simply placed my sandwich on the counter to cut it, without any paper underneath. Additionally, I noticed that none of the staff were wearing hair nets, which is concerning in the food industry. I do enjoy the sandwiches, but I recommend that headquarters take a look at this location in France, as it may not stay open for much longer if these issues aren't addressed.

Kailyn

2/5

The food was really good, but one of the staff members was quite rude. My friend mentioned to another friend that the salad was brown, and that seemed to trigger a lengthy explanation from the worker insisting it wasn’t actually brown. This was followed by her unkind attitude when I went to pay, and it felt as though she had a negative demeanor the whole time. Overall, the service left a bad impression. Book a table now

Natalie

5/5

I had the #3 Ham and Provolone sandwich, and it was fantastic! It was perfectly seasoned, and I ordered extra meat and cheese, which made it even better. It was the ideal choice for a hot day when I just didn’t want to cook, haha. A big thank you to the staff for making such an amazing sandwich!

Gigi

5/5

The sandwiches are always delicious! This time, I ordered hot sandwich on a wrap. Most likely will not do that again. The wrap is falling apart and a good portion of it stuck to the paper. The sandwich is delicious, but will definitely avoid the hot sandwich on a wrap.

Michael

5/5

The sandwiches are fresh and delicious. Unlike other sandwich places, Jersey Mike's generously fills their sandwiches with plenty of meat and cheese. You definitely get good value for your money.

Alberto

1/5

Don't go to this location, very unprofessional and unorganized. They gave me the wrong order and made it seem like its happens all the time not even giving me a resolution to fix their error. Book a table now

Diamond

5/5

Ordered off Postmates so I can’t attest to the customer service, but gosh dang these subs were amazing. So much better than I thought. I honestly feel this was better than my local sub shop.

Adrian

4/5

The #8 club sub was excellent; it would have been even better with some bacon!


Dishes

Cookie
Cookie

#6 Roast Beef And Provolone
#6 Roast Beef And Provolone

#2 Jersey Shore's Favorite
#2 Jersey Shore's Favorite

#11 Stickball Special
#11 Stickball Special

#4 The Number Four
#4 The Number Four

#12 Cancro Special
#12 Cancro Special

#9 Club Supreme
#9 Club Supreme

#14 The Veggie
#14 The Veggie

The Super Sub
The Super Sub

Blt
Blt