"The best cheese pizza in town! Superior ingredients, and Jimmy always makes us feel welcome."
Phone: +19146985804
Address: 808 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, United States Of America, 10543
Reservation, Booking
City: Mamaroneck
Website: http://jimmyspizza.com
Dishes: 2
Categories: 4
Reviews: 274
I had never been to Jimmy's before, but I had heard they had great pizza. I was not disappointed. I ordered a large pizza, had a pleasant chat with one of the staff members, and was asked if it was my first time trying their pizza. It was cooked in a pan and then baked in the oven, resulting in a perfectly crispy crust. The pizza was delicious straight from the box and just as tasty when reheated at home in the toaster.
This is a charming little restaurant with a cozy atmosphere. We arrived just before closing time, but the owner was more than happy to prepare a cake for us. We had a pleasant conversation with the owner before he closed up for the night. The service was warm and welcoming, giving off a comforting, old-world vibe.
First time there, we ordered just before closing and Jimmy made us a perfect mushroom pizza with the freshest ingredients. Ask him to make it however he thinks it's best- trust me he knows! Delicious pizza and a dedicated owner making everything the way it should be. We'll be back!
Jimmy's isn't just the best pizza in Mamaroneck... it's easily top 5 in the county! Ask for the pies well done if you like a crispy crust and don't forget to grab a salad with your pie. His homemade dressing is addictive!! Book a table now
I can't express enough how delicious Jimmy's pizza is! We decided to try the calzone as well, and it was probably the best I've ever had. Thanks for serving us the best, Jimmy.
Love the cheese pizza here. I always go back for the same thing, a plain cheese personal sized pizza. You can call and ask about the daily specials. Parking is on the street.
Jimmy was all he built. Had a personal pizza with sausage. The woman had one with mushrooms and my son had a simple cut. Jimmy had a big conversation
The best cheese pizza in town! Superior ingredients, and Jimmy always makes us feel welcome. Book a table now
327 AveNY 10543, Mamaroneck, United States
Reservation, Vegetarian, Asiatic, Chicken, Indian
"Delicious food, amazing ambience, friendly service, love everything abt this place."
2325 Boston Post Road, 10538, LARCHMONT, United States
Reservation, Vegetarian, Sandwiches, Mexican, Pizza, Grill
"BEC was fantastic"
974 E. Boston Post Rd. Mamaroneck, NY 10543, 10543-4123, United States
Reservation, Italian, Seafood, Cheese, Pasta, Beer
"Always outstanding great food welcoming staff and owners"
109 Halstead ave Harrison, NY 10528, 10528-4152, United States
Reservation, Latin-american, Peruvian, Japanese, Seafood, Chinese
"Delicious food and refreshing drinks on a hot evening."
2098 Boston Post Road Larchmont, NY 10538, 10538-3745, LARCHMONT, United States
Reservation, Contemporary, Vegetarian, American, Pizza
"Inattentive, rushed, and pushy service with an empty restaurant. No thanks"
