Next, I tried the Skye salmon dish with Israeli couscous, requesting it to be cooked medium. Unfortunately, what I received was rare, undercooked fish, coated in a seasoning that lacked flavor and just looked good. This was another disappointment.
Additionally, the restaurant has undergone a complete redesign that stripped away the elegant ambiance it once had, turning it into what feels more like a sports bar. These two major failures led me to give Legal Seafoods only one star.
However, the mussels were excellent, which lifted my spirits a bit, even though I’m not eager to return or recommend it to someone I want to impress. I decided to stretch my rating to three stars, thanks to the...
The staff was exceptional. The female bartender was friendly and welcoming, and she made great suggestions for my meal. I ordered the Crab Cake dinner, and it was the best I've ever had. She also encouraged me to try the Bread Pudding for dessert, and I was truly impressed—it was just perfect. I highly recommend trying it, even if you only get that. Overall, I’m very pleased with my experience.
Everytime I am in shorthills NJ I will be ordering from here. Flavor 10/10 Quality 10/10 communication 10/10 Service 10/10. I am a new customer for life now . Plus my wife loved it, so thats an obvious win there. We ordered the Baked Stuffed Lobster, Crispy Calamari, and the Fish Tacos. Every single thing was cooked perfectly and tasted amazing! Thank you forbeing the best at what you do.
I always have a great dining experience when I visit this restaurant. The location is convenient, and the food is consistently fresh. This time, I decided to try something new, and the scallops were fantastic—they complemented the rice pilaf perfectly. They also offer a nice variety of drinks. The service was excellent, with my server being very attentive. I will definitely return.
Book a table now
It never fails that food here is a great experience. The staff was pleasant, the ambience is stylish and relaxing, the food was GREAT! So happy they brought back the Thai Calamari. My seafood combination plate was well flavored and absolutely delicious. My fiancée also enjoyed his seafood steak meal. We will definitely be back! Great opportunity to pack a day of shopping :
Dining here is always a wonderful experience. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is elegant and calming, and the food is excellent! I’m thrilled they brought back the Thai calamari. My seafood combo plate was full of flavor and absolutely delicious. My fiancé also loved his seafood steak dish. We’ll definitely return! A perfect way to end a day of shopping.
Food is good like the Simply Grilled Colossal Shrimp and the Colossal Naked Shrimp Cocktail. Fried foods are a little soggy upon arrival and the store did not include the crackers that go with their delicious New England Clam Chowder, so that was disappointing. The small dinner rolls are always wonderful!
The baked stuffed lobster was dry and flavorless. I have dined at legal often. I see it as my go to. The delivery was perfumery, and actually could not be consumed. We threw away 64.00 of this 97.00 order and ha a ham and cheese sandwich. I will NEVER order from or dine there again. Quite disappointed,
Book a table now
The burger is excellent! Great flavor and awesome choice for those who don't like seafood. The grilled salmon is great too.
Everything was overcooked and small portions. Not appealing for the high price Ipaid.
Herb Crusted Salmon*, Organic Sea Harvest, Isle Of Skye
Legal's Signature Crab Cake Combo
Gigante Bean, Kale, Tomato Stew
Colossal Naked Shrimp Cocktail
Steamed Gulf Of Maine Lobster
Legal's Signature Crab Cake
Kids' House-Made Mac Cheese
Sesame Soy Roasted Broccoli
Blackened Raw Tuna Tataki
Kids' Burger/Cheeseburger
