Magdalena’s Pizzeria

Order from somewhere else, we will never order from here again. Always amazing in the past, but not so much in 2022. They completely messed up our last 2 orders, and the phone is always off the hook so you can?t even talk to anyone about it. Its almost as if they send you want they want you to eat. Very bizarre. As a matter of fact they?ve messed up almost every order this year, but we never said anything bc I liked the owner felt really bad that his wife passed away. I?m wondering if he sold it. Sizing is inconsistent with the pizzas they come super soggy as of late. Bummed to lose a neighborhood spot.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Hands down the BEST pizza I?ve EVER had. The flavors and taste are unmatched and they?re obviously using premium ingredients. Normally pizza will give me some minor heartburn every single time I eat it, but I haven?t experienced that once with Magdalena?s. Their Bocci balls are to die for and their 5 cheese, BBQ chicken and chicken bacon ranch are absolutely unbeatable!

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

It was good alfredo fettuccine. I liked the garlic knots that came with it and the side salad. I also ordered a small cheese pizza. The crust was crispy and was delicious. Also ordered a calzone but didn't like the ricotta cheese in it. Was too much. Ordered here again and the crust was good thickness/thinness. Not a fan of the garlic knots though.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

I don't know if they sold it to someone else or what, but there were all new people when we left. Usually you get the pizza rolls that are fantastic, but you said they didn't have to do. I don't think they knew how they were done. Wound up always meat lovers pizza and it was terrible. I hope they didn't sell because they used to be the best place.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Great food and great staff. Definitely recommend it. The pizza and side dishes are delicious Authentic NY flavor.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply