Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Italian Eatery

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Italian Eatery

374 Windsor Hwy, 12553, New Windsor, US, United States
133 Reviews 4

"My first time eating there...the pizza reminded me of NYC pizza. I will be going there again."

Details

Phone: (+1)8455616262

Address: 374 Windsor Hwy, 12553, New Windsor, US, United States

City: New Windsor

Website: http://mamatheresasnewwindsor.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:00 -22:00

Tuesday: 11:00 -22:00

Wednesday: 11:00 -22:00

Thursday: 11:00 -22:00

Friday: 11:00 -22:00

Saturday: 11:00 -22:00

Sunday: 12:00 -21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 4

Amenities: 5

Categories: 5

Reviews: 133


Address

Show Map

Reviews

1 /5 Rating

Hands down one of the single worst pizzas in the area! Ordered a large pepperoni pie. It was greasy as hell. On top of that, their large is about the size of most place's small pie. Making matters worse, are their exorbitant prices.... the pizza, an over priced $8 app, and a bottle of water was $30!! Most expensive pizza in the area. Not worth the price, not even close. Will never go back and I suggest you stay away too!

5 /5 Rating

best Italian place to go for deli and pizza. pizza always on point, excellent Italian sandwiches, actual philly style cheese steaks, and huge portions suppe that can feed like 3-4 people for $5. don't waste their time trying out places, just go here

3 /5 Rating

Thinnest slice around! but slice included odd aftertaste. Plus: Storefront requires you to wear a mask, but staff and pizza guy don’t wear them themselves.

5 /5 Rating

Ordered catering from Mama Theresa's. Food was delicious. Delivery was on time and delivery person was great with setting up everything.

5 /5 Rating

My first time eating there...the pizza reminded me of NYC pizza. I will be going there again.


Dishes

Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Chicken

Ravioli
Ravioli

Fried Ravioli
Fried Ravioli

Garlic Knots
Garlic Knots