**Service:** Delivery
**Meal Type:** Brunch
**Price per Person:** $1–10
**Food Rating:** 5
**Service Rating:** 5
**Atmosphere Rating:** 5
**Recommended Dish:** 16-inch Pizza
I had a fantastic experience with Middlebury Pizza! The delivery service was prompt and friendly, making the brunch even more enjoyable. The pizza was absolutely delicious, earning a perfect rating from me. The atmosphere, even from the comfort of my home, felt vibrant and welcoming. I highly recommend trying the 16-inch pizza; it’s a must-have!
As a regular customer, I was quite disappointed with my recent experience. I ordered a pizza on Halloween night, which I understand can be busy. I was given a pickup time of an hour and fifteen minutes, which seemed reasonable. However, when I arrived at the specified time, I was informed that it would take an additional 30-45 minutes. This is completely unacceptable. It's important to provide accurate time estimates upfront or at least call to update customers with any changes. Overall, the customer service was lacking.
I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, and roasted red peppers, asking for it to be well done. It came out perfectly cooked, featuring fantastic flavor, a thin crust, and ample toppings! Overall, I give the food a 5, the service a 4, and the atmosphere a 4.
I absolutely love Middlebury Pizza for everything it stands for. With its hometown charm, commitment to employing local youth, and a menu featuring fantastic thin crust pizza alongside the best Penne a la Vodka you'll find anywhere, it’s truly a special place.
Book a table now
We ordered several pizzas from Middlebury Pizza for a party, and everything was excellent. The pizzas came hot and fresh, and the service was exceptional. We enjoyed the cheese, pepperoni, veggie, and eggplant pizzas, all of which were delicious.
I haven't come across a place that serves bad pizza slices! I tried the Italiano pizza and it was fantastic! It had a nice thin crust that was perfectly crispy without being overly crunchy. I definitely recommend it!
Middlebury Pizza offers fantastic pizza and grinders. I've been a loyal customer for at least 15 years, and I've never been disappointed. The staff is always friendly! Their menu has something for everyone.
I just grabbed a large meatball and onion pizza after a long week, and I knew I was in for a delight as soon as I picked up the box. They really nailed it! It was an excellent pizza.
Book a table now
The owner was nasty and told us to leave because my son who has autism banged on the table once. I will never set foot in that place.
The pizza was absolutely average and wicked expensive. It was the first time we had gone there and will be the last.
