For my daughter, we ordered a prosciutto and salami sub, and let me say, the photos don’t do it justice. The staff were friendly and accommodating; one of the guys even gave my daughter a chocolate chip cookie from the counter, which was a thoughtful touch. I was genuinely surprised at how much I enjoyed our meal. I initially thought the prices were on the higher side, but the sandwich sizes are definitely substantial enough for two people or for two servings. The only downside is the parking, which is limited to the side streets and can be challenging, and there isn’t any seating available outside or inside the restaurant.
What an amazing experience I just had ordering from Mike’s! We ordered through doordash and I wanted to add broccoli rabe to my sandwich. A very nice man called to confirm and I said not to worry about the addition if it was a problem. He said not at all! I’ll take care of you! They even added a little dessert to our order. Talk about a great business ethic and taking care of your customers! Best of all the sandwiches and salads were absolutely delicious!!! Thank you Mike’s for your outstanding food and your unmatched customer service???
#shoplocal #supportlocalbusiness @mikespastasandwichshoppe the specials of today #nutley #nutleynj I wish I could go back in time and get one of those tubs of vodka sauce. Omg I could dip this into it….(yes they sell those too) lol LITERALLY a gentleman sitting as soon as you walk in…making pasta. Just like a ninja, slicing the perfect lengths and gently putting them down. All lined up. Such a great sandwich. Good recommendation @katierealtorperez
Premium sandwiches. This place takes all the common ingredients you know and love in a sandwich and elevates it. There are many other places to go for ordinary turkey cheese sandwiches, but I come here for their specialty sandwiches. They really put a lot of thought into the menu and ingredients. I’ve bought a few types of sandwiches, some of their handmade pasta you can see them make when you walk in and I can say I never leave unsatisfied.
Book a table now
Went with my daughter after seeing the spicy grilled cheese highlighted in the paper. Old deli feel with homemade salads and refrigerated sauces/pasta to go. My chicken cutlet sandwich was huge and very good. My daughter's spicy grilled cheese was a whole heck of a lot of cheese and she said it was very good. Two sandwiches and a 1/2 pound of potato salad were $31.99 but I would definitely go back again.
I absolutely loved their eggplant sandwich! It was fantastic. They also serve some of the best fresh pasta I've ever tried. A friend recently gifted me the spinach pasta, and I cooked it today with a pesto Alfredo sauce, which turned out amazing. I will definitely be rushing back for more!
This was my first visit, and it definitely won't be my last! The sandwich was fantastic—chicken cutlet, mozzarella, and broccoli rabe were absolutely delicious! The portions were huge! I also tried the fresh spaghetti with sauce and mini meatballs, and I loved those too!
One of the best places around In north jersey. Sandwhiches, pasta, even the small items around the store are all top quality. The creativity sets them apart from the crowd. The sandwhich specials are always amazing. The best of the best.
Book a table now
I absolutely love Mike and everything he's ever prepared for me. From the sandwiches to our large party catering orders, everyone is always impressed! Thank you, Mike, and I'll see you soon!
This place is THE SPOT. The staff are all polite and the food is always fresh and delectable. The most beautiful sandwiches come from Mike’s.
Sweet Italian Sausage In Marinara
San Carlo Italian Potato Chips
Eggplant Parm Platter (Frozen)
Meatballs In Marinara (Quart)
Chicken Parm Platter (Frozen)
Chick Pea Salad (Half Tray)
House Made Pasta And Sauce
